Ghazanfar Ali Generator - Utlilizing trapped energy

[JJUK]

@poynt99

Do you believe that ORCAD SPICE provides a more accurate simulation of the real world than Multisim then? I merely downloaded the Multisim 30 day trial https://lumen.ni.com/nicif/us/evalmultisim/content.xhtml as that was the file format being used by Ali. I am wondering whether I should be using ORCAD instead.

[poynt99]

Although it is possible Multisim may be simulating the circuit incorrectly, I doubt it is.

I am fairly good at using PSpice and obtaining the required measurements, so that is one reason I'd like to see the ORCAD files with the circuit operating the same as the Multisim. I will be able to get to the meat of the matter very quickly.

.99

[djex81]

@poynt99

Do you believe that ORCAD SPICE provides a more accurate simulation of the real world than Multisim then? I merely downloaded the Multisim 30 day trial https://lumen.ni.com/nicif/us/evalmultisim/content.xhtml as that was the file format being used by Ali. I am wondering whether I should be using ORCAD instead.

Hello all, I'm new here I guess you can say. Been watching this thread and lurking here for awhile now. I think if we are going to use a simulator to test anything we need to run this on multiple simulators to rule out a software anomaly. One thing that worries me is that these results may be a miscalculation by the simulation software. Though similar results are shown between Multisim and OrCAD we should also try other software's (even the free ones) to see if the results are the same or at least still suggesting OU. Each software may use a different calculation method and if multiple calculation methods show possible OU then it's a good chance that the results are accurate or at least telling the truth.

I'll see if I can get a TinaTI sim ready using the latest v1.5 schematic.

[forest]

Couple of questions from somebody who has always a lot of worries 


1. IRFP260 is the same as IRFP260N ?
2. Assuming that we will choose a circuit for driving mosfets; cold someone explain how that circuit (powered from 9V battery from example) could drive mosfets without grounds of oscillator and proposed circuit merged ? That always bothered me and I still can't get it properly : how to join two circuits : one with flowing large currents at 50V and more and one requiring only 9V and a few mA maybe.Of course we need also to eliminate leakage of power from oscillator to proposed OU circuit.

[e2matrix]

poynt99,  while it may be good to know where the simulator energy is coming from what actual benefit does this have if  simulator's are not going to simulate tapping radiant energy or energy from other unseen or unknown sources as may be the case with the actual circuit here?