Testing the TK Tar Baby

[MileHigh]

Just in case this comes in handy:

[Rosemary Ainslie]

I will NOT answer your questions picowatt.  Any more than I'd answer questions as to whether or not I can read - or spell - or write - or talk.  You are relying on this utterly highhanded patronising series of questions and answers to ENDORSE your opinion that I need to be spoken to at the level of an IDIOT.

I have no further intention of engaging with you unless and until you show some level of respect for my intelligence.

So NO.  I will not answer your questions.

Rosemary

[MileHigh]

Rosemary:

I will NOT answer your questions picowatt.  Any more than I'd answer questions as to whether or not I can read - or spell - or write - or talk.  You are relying on this utterly highhanded patronising series of questions and answers to ENDORSE your opinion that I need to be spoken to at the level of an IDIOT.

I have no further intention of engaging with you unless and until you show some level of respect for my intelligence.

So NO.  I will not answer your questions.

You saw my posting.  Spend several hours per day over the course of two days and come back here with a basic competency about MOSFETs.  There are five or six key concepts that need to be understood if you want to try and understand how your circuit works.

You are years late in making the effort to understand the basic concepts so that you can understand the standard terminology and communicate using the standard terminology.

Not knowing what drain to source resistance means is totally unacceptable.

MileHigh

[Rosemary Ainslie]

Rosemary:

You saw my posting.  Spend several hours per day over the course of two days and come back here with a basic competency about MOSFETs.  There are five or six key concepts that need to be understood if you want to try and understand how your circuit works.

You are years late in making the effort to understand the basic concepts so that you can understand the standard terminology and communicate using the standard terminology.

Not knowing what drain to source resistance means is totally unacceptable.

MileHigh

Your advices here MileHigh - as ever - would be better applied to yourself.  I know considerably more about MOSFETs - self evidently - than either you or picowatt.  Not only that but picowatt is utterly out of line.  You - I would expect to rely on that 'Rosemary knows NOTHING' bit.   Picowatt needs to explain his argument.  He has first endorsed TK's findings - which were WRONG.  He is now endorsing Groundloop's argument - without even seeing where it goes.  And optionally - as the whim takes him - he is ALSO endorsing Poynty's argument which is possibly the only one that still has any intellectual merit.  So.  From that I'd suspect that he's ready to fall in with anything that comes along - in the hopes of something being 'right'.  And up till now he has NOT explained his argument.  I'm waiting for it.

Rosemary

[MileHigh]

Rosemary:

No, the burden must fall on you this time to put in your own effort to educate yourself about MOSFETs and then come back here and continue the discussion.  It's simply ridiculous that this late in the game that you don't even posses a mastery of the most basic terminology (and one would assume associated technical concepts) related to MOSFETs.

It's simply unacceptable.

Your self-evaluation of your knowledge is pure bluff and everybody reading this thread knows that's the case.

Repeat:  Come back in a few days after you understand MOSFETs.  Perhaps then you will be able to have a rational discussion with PW.

MileHigh