quentron.com

[MarkE]

So you can't answer my question then teacher mark E.great.this doesn't help.

You should know by now that I will not answer the question until you present an argument for your claim that the gapped "C" core of dissimlar metals gives rise to a thermodynamically reversible process.  You are free to propose any reason you like as to why I won't play your game the way you might like.  If you are taking the position that I must teach you something in order for you to articulate an argument, then you are tacitly admitting that you do not have an argument to offer.  As we have been going round and round without your presenting an argument for your claims, it certainly looks to me like you never had one.

[profitis]

Uh-uh @mark E. It doesn't work like that.I asked you if I could ask you a question.you said yes.I asked you a question.I got no answer.we are now stuck until somebody can answer my question.I just want to know if the two pieces-o-metal are going to sit there in the vaccuum and stay neutral when seperated.if they are then we have a problem.

[profitis]

Even if they only partially chargeup spontaneously over the gap we have a problem.

[sarkeizen]

What do you mean @sarkeizen

I've defined "formal argument" about ten times for you in this thread.  Thanks for being an asshole yet again.

A formal argument is where each step logically forces the next one.  That is there is no possibility of the second not being true if the first is true.

[MarkE]

Uh-uh @mark E. It doesn't work like that.I asked you if I could ask you a question.you said yes.I asked you a question.I got no answer.we are now stuck until somebody can answer my question.I just want to know if the two pieces-o-metal are going to sit there in the vaccuum and stay neutral when seperated.if they are then we have a problem.

LOL.  It seems you will try to make up any excuse for the fact that you have so far failed to support your extraordinary claim with any kind of logical argument.  If as you seem to be saying, that you need me or anyone else to tutor you in order for you to form your argument, then you never had one, and your extraordinary claim remains false on its face.