quentron.com

[profitis]

@gianni and sarkeizen..err..so you are saying that a steady flow of delta h solar heat just happens to be following the tinfoil wherever it is in the room ey. Ok lets put it in a perfect isothermal room,now tell me why its not gona work here.

[profitis]

@gianna.a perfect isothermal system is simply not necessary to prove a 2nd law violation if the device produces enough power to rule out your usual ambient interferences,solar,radiowaves,and random temperature gradients.       

[profitis]

@gianna.it is obvious that you dont understand reality.the reality is that in whichever room you put the foil it is going to heat its focal point above the average temperature of the room,insulated or not insulated.try it.and while we argue over wether its a 2nd law buster or not somebody is going to patent it and get rich on it.

[Groundloop]

.

[profitis]

@giannia.lets simplify the whole issue by asking if a concave mirror will focus and concentrate some light on its focal point in a ideal isothermal box of diffuse light.the answer is yes do you agree?