quentron.com

[sarkeizen]

I tell you what:  Once you come up with a reference such as I asked for, then I will review that reference and we can discuss the matter further.

Never. Going. To. Happen.

i tell you what @mark E, lets go with your flow,lets block communion between the gas of the 2 half-cells to make it easier for you and take it from there shall we? That removes your doubts regarding communion yes?

QED.

[MarkE]

i tell you what @mark E, lets go with your flow,lets block communion between the gas of the 2 half-cells to make it easier for you and take it from there shall we? That removes your doubts regarding communion yes?

I don't know why you would even suggest that since a number of messages back I stated that communication is required.  I don't think the idea that I would agree to removing a required element makes any sense.

When you come up with a reference as requested then I can review that reference and see if that changes my understanding.

[MarkE]

Never. Going. To. Happen.
QED.

My never threshold for this request is a week.

[profitis]

@sarkeizen we are still waiting for you to show that textbooks dont necessitate perpetual batteries QED.you can see ive got mark E in a corner here,thats why he,s demanding a ref for a perpetual motion device.

[profitis]

@mark E gaseous communion is necessary for a gaseous concentration cell? Since when?cmon mark, lets seperate the electrodes with a gas valve and build up a pressure differiential,whaddayasay