Looped SMOT

[gyulasun]

Very exciting but where is the web http:// address? Norman

Hi Norman,   

I found the video on youtube  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=igIzfTyAW9c   Indeed it is strange that Igor Belenskiy usually speaks in his videos (and youtube provides subtitles quasi for all so that we can get English from Russian) but in this video he does not speak.     

He has two channels, this one where the above video is included:   
https://www.youtube.com/c/%D0%98%D0%B3%D0%BE%D1%80%D1%8C%D0%91%D0%B5%D0%BB%D0%B5%D1%86%D0%BA%D0%B8%D0%B9/videos   

and this one  https://www.youtube.com/c/IgorBeletskiy/videos 

He has replicated lots of devices, and has been willing to consider pieces of advice, comments on certain claimed perpetual motion setups...   

Whether he faked the above video or not is not known by me, IMHO the principle may work...   

Gyula 

[floodrod]

I watched the video in slow motion and plotted the positions of the 2 balls.  The poster waited and timed the release of the 2nd ball when the first was 180 degrees away. And they stay in that position throughout.  Since the claim is so spectacular, it requires spectacular evidence.  There is great possibility there is a 2 pole magnet rotor under the table which is dragging the balls..

To believe- I would need to see the poster place the 2nd ball on the track right when the first ball passes (without pushing it)  and let them collide- to prove there is not a 2 pole rotor underneath.  Of course with no camera cuts

[citfta]

As some of you know I have spent many many hours working with magnets.  I find this device very hard to believe.  The first problem I see is that it is almost impossible to find two magnets that have exactly the same strength and field of magnetic force.  To find six magnets with exactly the same magnetic fields I think would be very close to impossible.  And if they weren't all the same strength then the device wouldn't run.  The other problem I see is how do you get the ball attracted enough to the magnet to go up the ramp but not jump on up to the  magnet above.  I saw where he spent a lot of time making adjustments but I think that was just for show.  If you look closely at his track and magnets the magnets all seem to be the same distance from the track.  But it there was any variation at all in the magnetic fields the magnets would need to be individually adjustable.  But his magnet holding frame is made so that adjusting one end of one magnet is going to change the end of the next magnet also.  Sorry, but I just see too many things in that video that don't match up with the reality of working with magnets.
Respectfully,
Carroll


PS: I think floodrod has it nailed.

[r2fpl]

The channel makes money from watching.