Mylow Motor was a fake

[rMuD]

(re-post from Howard Johnson Replication Tube Claim)

Voilà,
   
I put the events (zooming, shaky camera ,....) on the graph in relation with time...
see for your self.


if an addition or correction should be made, please let me know.

Thanks,
LightRider

I see no proof of a drive wire running in this video, infact my theory is that there is no string/wire motor used in this video...

Assuming this is the video we are talking about is http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hpQA5c9guvE&feature=channel_page

My theory on this is that he turned it by hand in this video.  There was never a time that during acceleration was the disk fully in view of the camera.

at the second spin up, he moves the stator in, the afterwards it starts up around 5m 50sec

Anyway hope were talking about the same video

[TinselKoala]

I see no proof of a drive wire running in this video, infact my theory is that there is no string/wire motor used in this video...

Assuming this is the video we are talking about is http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hpQA5c9guvE&feature=channel_page

My theory on this is that he turned it by hand in this video.  There was never a time that during acceleration was the disk fully in view of the camera.

at the second spin up, he moves the stator in, the afterwards it starts up around 5m 50sec

Anyway hope were talking about the same video

If LR's graph is good (and I'm sure it is) there are 2 indications that the hand is not the culprit:
First, the accelerations are too slow. A hand spin results in an acceleration that lasts less than one second; in the graph LR shows that the periods of acceleration are several seconds long, as much as 6 or 7 seconds.
Second, there are periods of constant speed. This is impossible to achieve with hand spinning.

EDIT: Note the right half of this graph. The accelerations due to my hand, even trying to be as smooth and slow as possible, still result in very steep acceleration curves, with NO constant speed at the peaks, since the wheel is not being driven.
The acceleration curves that LR has shown for Mylow's vid are not consistent with a hand push, but rather a slipping drive line that was readjusted several times and never really got stable.
IMHO.

[markdansie]

I cnat believe we are still on about the strings. Even Mylow confessed and there was some damming evidence put up yesterday that number 6 was a fake as well.
So to all replicators....learn what Mylow did wrong. The cogging effect is the exact oppersite of what you are after
Mark

[grayone]

I cnat believe we are still on about the strings. Even Mylow confessed and there was some damming evidence put up yesterday that number 6 was a fake as well.
So to all replicators....learn what Mylow did wrong. The cogging effect is the exact oppersite of what you are after
Mark

markdansie; I believe that it is still going on due to some different approaches that need further study in case there is something that can be used, despite of the fake.

[wattsup]

@TK

The only thing we cannot replicate right now with the graphs is what a real magnet wheel with a non-symmetric magnet arrangement should look like as in Video 6. It could actually look like what you have shown above.

@All

OK, regarding Video 17 Couch Motor and String Length. I am putting this photo below at the couch. What I did was drew the wheel to real scale and put the image under it, then just changed the wheel perspective but keeping it the same size, then drew in my lines from the 2" shaft going to the left of the stator bridge vertical, which I added in also. According to my best calculations, if there is a string in Video 17, it cannot be more then 0.4" or 10.16mm apart right near the left bridge post. If there are two strings going under the wheel, one will be curved to the back of the wheel shaft and the other will go in fairly straight to the front side of the shaft so you should look for a v-shaped thin shifting right at the stator pole base.

Based on the glass table and couch motor not being moved on my extrapolations for Video 19 where the Finns took the two string grab, the bridge was on a rubber mat and the alignment was not the same as in Video 17.
You can see on the next two images, the first shows Video 17 the bridge center post further to the left compared to the tables center support beam then the next image of Video 19.

The Video 19 bridge was about 0.75" more to the right so this would infer that the strings would be about 1.15" - 1.35" apart at the stator base. This would seem consistent with the image grabbed and outlined by the Finns and if these lines were added to the image, they made a real good approximation of where they should be placed.

This actually for me now confirms that Video 19 was faked.

But what has to also be understood in this Video 19 is the message Mylow was sending to us because of all the abuse he got during his first videos up to Video 6, which I think is real. In fact, I think the bar magnets are also real but the rotation speed would never have reached the faking method and he did this to to spite us all. Some people do not take insults very well. Who does?

So back to Video 6 after these commercials. lol