Claimed OU circuit of Rosemary Ainslie

[Rosemary Ainslie]

thanks Hoppy.  Got it.  I think the only questionably 'low' values were at the shunt.  But I hear you.  It would be good to check on this.

Thank you Hoppy. 

[powercat]

Wow look at TK's new work   

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UFHNY38GQsI
More Description Will Be Inserted Soon_
I will make the circuit available as soon as I can make a nice drawing of it. That is, "soon."
If you are interested, please be patient and don't flood me with requests; I will post it somewhere as soon as the drawing is done.
Unlike many circuits you might find in this particular area of research, this one does not use any components made of unobtainum or that must be ordered in from Alpha Ophiuchi 8. You can just about still get everything at RatShack.

well done TK
cat

[poynt99]

If there is a net zero current flow from the delivery of a battery supply source - then what measurement would prove this? Zero? Greater zero? Less zero? Where are your brains? How can a zero net loss be proven if any measurement at zero is considered NOISE?

I'm posting this answer here to accommodate any readers who do not read both forums and both threads.  Else your conclusions here will be the only one on record.  You'll note the edit but this is, in any event, for the record together with this second post reference and a second marginal edit.

And with reference to 'faulty meter' read uncalibrated, insensitive, whatever you want. I'm simply stating that it may not be equal to the required voltage measurement. Let me remind you - it was required by you. And - let me stress, the Tektronix is well able to deal with this measurement. It entirely eludes me why you should have wanted an alternative instrument unless you were looking for inferior data. I also do not understand why Aaron ever obliged you here. The real joke is that having done the measurement which you called for - you then discount it on the basis of the the instrument not giving a correct value. So, so strange. You really do treat us like idiots.

Then in all fairness you should have also posted my responses subsequent to yours. You answered my post here based on a different post elsewhere.

The meter is not capable of measuring the levels of voltage in the circuit, so it is NOT a reliable indicator of net direction. The -5.4mV was taken right from the scope samples, and this is buried in a sea of noise, and can not be reliably taken as a solid indicator of net direction, particularly with the large number of "spiky" samples that are "out of trend" with adjacent data.

.99

[Rosemary Ainslie]

Poynt - which meter?  The voltmeter you required or the tektronix which recorded the original samples?  Which of these two meters cannot record the 'spikes'?

And what is it about the voltage over the load resistor that is too insignificant to constitute anything but noise. 

The switch was being run off the same battery as the test.  It's nominal wattage is plus/minus 0.4.  The Fet was hot - the battery recharged and the two load resistors 100 watt each - both recorded a loss of over 1 degree below ambient.  And both voltmeters recorded a negative voltage across the shunt indicating a zero loss to the battery and a possible recharge.  the battery did recharge and over an extended run period.  Since when has a switch run and yet recharged a battery?  And where has a switching circuit run a load cool?

And if there was zero energy being lost at the battery - again, what number must the voltmeters or the tektronix give to prove this if not zero or less than zero?   And while it is valid to suggest that the voltmeter may not have managed the data it is entirely invalid to suggest that the Tektronix could not handle the frequency or the number. 

[Rosemary Ainslie]

Wow look at TK's new work   

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UFHNY38GQsI
More Description Will Be Inserted Soon_
I will make the circuit available as soon as I can make a nice drawing of it. That is, "soon."
If you are interested, please be patient and don't flood me with requests; I will post it somewhere as soon as the drawing is done.
Unlike many circuits you might find in this particular area of research, this one does not use any components made of unobtainum or that must be ordered in from Alpha Ophiuchi 8. You can just about still get everything at RatShack.

well done TK
cat

thanks cat.  It would be nice if you could post it here or post a link here if you put it elsewhere.