Muammer Yildiz Magnet Motor

[sigmaX]

aaaaaannnddd  .... They answered me !!!!

Hi Enrique,

The inventor, Muammer Yildiz, is currently touring Europe to interest universities and investors for his invention. One of his presentations took place on Tuesday 20 April at Delft University of Technology for a select group of scientists from both Delft University of Technology and Eindhoven University of Technology.

Kind regards,
Ms Ineke Boneschansker
Science Information Officer TU Delft


Drs. Ineke Boneschansker
Adviseur wetenschapscommunicatie

TU Delft / Directie Marketing en Communicatie
Prometheusplein 1
2628 ZC Delft
Postbus 139
2600 AC Delft
T  +31 (0)15 27 88499
F  +31 (0)15 27 81855
E  i.boneschansker@tudelft.nl


Ik werk van maandag tot en met vrijdag.

[Omnibus]

to interest universities and investors for his invention

I guess "to interest universities" is put in there just for flavor. The real part is "to interest investors". How well known that is. If he really intends to get universities interested in this he should behave the way anybody doing research in a university setting behaves -- provide an open dissemination of what he thinks he has achieved. Investors are a different cup of tea and those interested in investors only use universities as a smoke screen to appear there's something really scientific going on, which may not actually be the case.

So, he went to Delft University, made a short presentation and that's it. From now on he may claim when talking to investors that it's been shown in universities. Is that it? Will Delft University allow to use their name in this way without further involvement to get to the bottom of the claim? How pathetic if that's the case.

[sigmaX]

Omnibus:

I hope it is not the case ... At least it seems he dissassembles the motor. It is also to be noted that there are students attending, and probably professors. It would be nice to hear from them, what do the think, what could they see, etc.

[JamesThomas]

There is something missing.

When you do a presentation of a new device it is general practice to have available technical data sheets that answer the bulk of the questions. Such sheets would have clearly drawn technical schematics, and actual power generation data acquired via the hundreds of hours of testing, tuning and retesting. Data which presents not only specifics of the actual device, but also environmental conditions when tests where done and all other circumstances that may influence the final numbers, not to mention the names and types of scientific measuring apparatus used.

Certainly if you where inventing such a "world changing" device, you would document everything and anything that was in anyway related to the development of your brainchild. To just present your "working" device in front of a scientifically minded audience and no data is disrespectful of your own hard work and leaves a huge vacuum that motivates thoughts of fraud.

Where's the meat? Where's the data? Is there any?

[Omnibus]

There is something missing.

When you do a presentation of a new device it is general practice to have available technical data sheets that answer the bulk of the questions. Such sheets would have clearly drawn technical schematics, and actual power generation data acquired via the hundreds of hours of testing, tuning and retesting. Data which presents not only specifics of the actual device, but also environmental conditions when tests where done and all other circumstances that may influence the final numbers, not to mention the names and types of scientific measuring apparatus used.

Certainly if you where inventing such a "world changing" device, you would document everything and anything that was in anyway related to the development of your brainchild. To just present your "working" device in front of a scientifically minded audience and no data is disrespectful of your own hard work and leaves a huge vacuum that motivates thoughts of fraud.

Where's the meat? Where's the data? Is there any?

Can't agree more.