Testing the TK Tar Baby

[Rosemary Ainslie]

Rosemary,

The simulation of your circuit will run perfectly fine using a big capacitor as the source rather than batteries, and with the oscillations abundantly intact as always. Why wouldn't it?

I am just curious why TK wants to see this.

THEN SHOW US POYNTY POINT.  We have replaced those batteries with a capacitor and the OSCILLATIONS DIE.  EVERY TIME.  ON EVERY SINGLE SETTING. 

Rosie

[poynt99]

THEN SHOW US POYNTY POINT.  We have replaced those batteries with a capacitor and the OSCILLATIONS DIE.  EVERY TIME.  ON EVERY SINGLE SETTING. 

Rosie

Rosemary,

It will work just fine with a sufficiently-large capacitor(s). What size capacitor (in uF) did you try?

[MileHigh]

Rosemary:

Poynty?  You know, TK knows - WE ALL KNOW - that a capacitor CANNOT enable that oscillation.  And we ALL KNOW WHY.

Really?  Perhaps you can explain it for the readers here and now.  I don't know why.

There are very little differences between a large charged capacitor and a battery from the perspective of them being power sources.  Can you tell us what they are and how this relates back to your allegation that a capacitor cannot enable that oscillation?  I am asking you for a technical explanation.

Meanwhile, I can just imagine the scene in my mind:  "Inherit the Zipon - The Scopes Electro-Monkey Trial."  LOL LOL LOL

MileHigh

[Rosemary Ainslie]

Rosemary,

It will work just fine with a sufficiently-large capacitor(s). What size capacitor (in uF) did you try?

I don't have the details and my collaborator who did these tests is  holidaying until Monday.  I'll let you know.

Rosie

[mrsean2k]

Rosemary, what specific technical claims of TKs do you consider insulting or actionable? If I agree with them I'll say so, and you can take whatever action you want.


As an adult you should be aware there's a distinction between you feeling insulted and an intention to insult specifically. Feel free to explore that distinction legally.


I'll make a further concession: I disagree with your reasoning on the matter, but I nevertheless make available legalcontact(at)seani(dot)justemail(dot)net - I presume that satisfies your sensitivity on that score.


And I invite our host to email at that address as proof its "mine" if he feels inclined.