Testing the TK Tar Baby

[picowatt]

My dear picowatt

If I ever needed any evidence of 'partiality' it's in this post of yours.  I most certainly HAVE NOT BEEN either unpleasant or unprofessional.  I think the most lenient of accusations would be to say that it is TK who has been excessively combative and entirely unprofessional.  ANd I'm NOT even confining this comment to his work.  And it is HE who has required that I don't engage.  So. PLEASE.  Exercise a modicum of reasonableness in your opinions related to this.  It's GLARINGLY inappropriate.

Regards
Rosemary

Rosemary,

I am fully aware of the attitude issues between you and TK.  But even in my discussions with you, simple questions always seemed to invoke an argument or confrontation from you, not a discussion. 

So I will respectfully disagree, I believe it is VERY reasonable to wish you, as well as TK, would "lighten up".

PW

[Rosemary Ainslie]

Note that last part especially. Here's the translation: "We didn't do the critical measurement to see if our conclusion is right because we know our conclusion is right so we don't have to."

Not actually.  Here's what we're saying.

'Notwithstanding the measured wattage delivered there appears to be consistent evidence of a negative product.  And a negative 'wattage' makes no sense.  And no matter what we factor in for impedance  -  that negative wattage persists.  So. Can you EXPERTS please explain this.  Because that's why we're writing this paper.'

Rosie Posie

[TinselKoala]

And here's another error.  We have examples where the battery indicates a negative voltage.  Go figger!

Again,
Rosie Pose

Prove it.
Not in any of the scopeshots in your "papers" is a negative battery voltage shown during even the highest oscillations.

[Rosemary Ainslie]

Rosemary,

I am fully aware of the attitude issues between you and TK.  But even in my discussions with you, simple questions always seemed to invoke an argument or confrontation from you, not a discussion. 

So I will respectfully disagree, I believe it is VERY reasonable to wish you, as well as TK, would "lighten up".

PW

picowatt - with respect - there has been nothing that you have posted to me that has not been addressed respectfully.  If you can show me any evidence to the contrary then I'll attend to it.

So.  When you include my attitude with that of TK's again you're wrong.  I do NOT resort to malicious invective nor traducement.  And my comments are NOT slanderous. 

Rosemary

[picowatt]

TK,

You are indeed fast.  I wish we had a part number for Rosemary's CSR resistors so that their inductance could be confirmed.

When you measured your CSR's inductance, did you measure them as paralleled or individually and then calculate their value?

In all the video blowups, has anyone seen a manufacturer logo on Rosemary's CSR's?

You don't need such high wattage for the CSR, I'll bet you could live with 4 to 8 half-watt carbons paralleled.

PW