KARPEN PILE

[MarkE]

And this video to destroy all of mark E's fantasies of the second law thermodynamics. A thick etched platinum wire is ANODIC,that's right my friends,anodic vs nickel-black exposed to air at surface of NaOH electrolyte.the blackened nickel(+) retaining greater O2 adsorption than the submerged platinum(-) giving rise to an oxygen concentration nernst value on the v-meter

Assuming for a moment that the experiment in an apparently dirty bottle cap was not polluted, and that the materials are as you represent them, how is it that you contend that what is shown in the video violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics?

[profitis]

Nah it gives perpetual power @mark E(same like karpen cell). viewers,varsity students,scientists can easily replicate this one.try maximize with larger electrodes.it won't work under pure argon or nitrogen by the way,only o2/air

[MarkE]

Nah it gives perpetual power @mark E(same like karpen cell). viewers,varsity students,scientists can easily replicate this one.try maximize with larger electrodes.it won't work under pure argon or nitrogen by the way,only o2/air

Is it your assertion that:
The cell operates without generating any reaction products from the inputs?  If that is not your assertion, then on what basis do you claim that it:  "gives perpetual power"?  Is it an assertion that a concentration changes indefinitely while remaining unbalanced indefinitely?  Clarification is needed to determine if you are making a claim against the First Law, or the Second Law.

[profitis]

It doesn't work under argon or nitrogen,only air or oxygen,which means o2 is without a shred of doubt involved in its electrode reactions.this is to be expected because the oxygen concentration is much larger at the nickel than at the platinum.after o2 concentrations are leveled out on discharge,opening switch allows recharge and re-distribution of original oxygen concentrations spontaneously. 100% reversable catalytic oxygen spillover from nickel onto platinum in this case.against kelvin rule.

[profitis]

Also note that corrosion current is impossible.according to standard table of potentials nickel must corrode by a exponentialy huge margin.