A Perspective On The B Type EESD - Robert Murray-Smith - Any issues?

[Nink]

All the aggro aside,Australia really is the best place on earth.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aZ4NuX0qWuY

I grew up in Australia but as an adult I have moved around the world.  Australians are an extremely resourceful culture. They are not afraid to try new things, nor are they afraid of failure. As a result Australians are some of the most innovative people in the world.

One of the challenges Australians have on the world stage is in relation to formal education. The focus in Australia on "western education" is not at the same level in comparison to  Europe (UK, Germany, Sweden) and North America (US, Canada). There is only one University from Australia in the top 50 world rankings. The University of Melbourne ranks in at 33 and a large percentage of the students attending are from overseas.

I actually do not believe this is a bad thing. The western education system certainly provides an environment for learning but my perception is they are also focused on telling people what they can't do versus "just give it a go" and try.   I struggled assimilating into other cultures as a result of this. In Australia making mistakes or trying something that does not work is not perceived as a failure, it is simply a lesson learned.

[tinman]

YOU have put me off kangaroo stake  now, i did not know they
are on steroids now.

Lol

Roger the Roo is over 2 meters tall,and weighs in at over 20 stone-127Kgs.
most of the older bucks are muscle bound.
Roger live on a reserve in Alice Springs.

[minnie]

   MileHigh, nearly everything on this forum comes under the "you must be joking"
sort of category. There's no need to address people with the nasty sort of tone
that you seem to be using a lot these days. For me it's a bit of entertainment and
I think that view is taken by many others. Kinetic energy rules!

[MileHigh]

   MileHigh, nearly everything on this forum comes under the "you must be joking"
sort of category. There's no need to address people with the nasty sort of tone
that you seem to be using a lot these days. For me it's a bit of entertainment and
I think that view is taken by many others. Kinetic energy rules!

When you get attacked for pointing out a gross gross error by somebody that is supposed to be the technical expert for a struggling little company in financial dire straights you are going to defend yourself.  Plus I got threatened, and that's real.  It's wise to question things and to question people's motives.  In the real world as opposed to the forums RMS's "error" would be quickly dealt with.  I am not a sheeple and I can clearly distinguish right from wrong.  There has been more nasty tone directed at me than me defending myself back.

As of right now there is no evidence of a special battery that outperforms a lithium-ion battery and there are no credible measurements of the value of the graphene-based supercapacitors that I am aware of.  There is just unsubstantiated talk.

Some choice quotes from my links.  Welcome to the real world:

Forget it, it's a complete scam! The claims don't even make sense: a hydrogen generator on board – presumably run by electricity – used to split water to produce hydrogen which in turn will be used in a fuel cell to produce electricity to run the car!

So. This company has come up with some excellent graphene batteries. How much would YOU pay to be the first to benefit from this awesome breakthrough? But wait! They also have developed a fool cell with onboard electrolyzation! NOW how much would you pay?
But wait! There's more! They have also designed a SUPERCARRRRRRRRRR! That's right, a Supercar! Incorporating All Three of these technologies that seem to have appeared out of thin air!
NOW how much would you pay???
Hmmmmm???

But as long as you have this amazing graphene battery splitting water in the tank to produce hydrogen, you can use that hydrogen to charge the battery and the car will run forever!  Right?
I agree this is a scam that ties the classic dream of a car that runs on water to the classic dream of a car that uses a magical 5-minute-to-charge battery all in a way that makes no physical sense.

"The fuel cell will be powered by an on demand Hydrogen generation unit built into the car and will only require water."
So then, this is just another perpetual motion scam.
An on-demand hydrogen generator would require far more energy to power than it would provide in hydrogen fuel. If they're claiming this would actually be practical, then it's a perpetual motion claim.

The article claims this car performs "on demand Hydrogen generation". That would not be powered by plugging it in. "On demand" means it's generated as needed while the car is driving down the road. As has been said, the only way to do that, in the vehicle as described, is to use electricity to generate hydrogen, which of course is then oxidized to produce a lot less electricity than it took to generate the hydrogen. There is no rational reason to do that; it would require expensive equipment which would do nothing but waste energy.
It's a scam, period.

[Jimboot]

You clearly threatened me like some jackass chav that wants to arrange a physical fight after a Facebook dispute.  Putting up your address is just a feint to try to make yourself look innocent after the fact.  Your address is out there already because you are a public Internet marketing consultant, so it's a meaningless gesture.

Your behaviour clearly demonstrates why I choose to be anonymous, Brad chooses to be anonymous, and 99.5% of the rest of the users on this forum choose to be anonymous.  We don't want the risk of having to deal with people like you in real life.

Er... I 'm connected with Brad on FB & Skype... we know his name is Brad... umm. I'm guessing the reason you are anonymous is so you can be an offensive l without repercussions. I did not attack you or threaten anyone can read the thread if they are bored out the brain and see that. You obviously don't get it. I care too much that's my problem.