THE RANT ROOM

[onepower]

SL

Analyze the concept, and if need be, construct a simple (or complex) Proof-of-Concept is need
be (e.g. B-H Curve analysis with graphs, etc; wind an air-core coil; measure it with a Tesla-Gauss
meter; insert a soft magnetic core; measure again. Now, go back and use the CAE Analysis to
show the same demonstrations. It works extremely well and is quite comprehensive.

That's cool but can you describe the actual rate of change of both the electric and magnetic field around a coil relating to the inverse square law as the current within it actually changes and not averaging the forces as most do?. You see as an engineer I cannot rely on hearsay or what someone 100 years ago claimed or said and it must be verified. This may be why a group of investors worth supposedly billions of dollars were seeking my advice versus others which means nothing. I do not rely on prior generalized knowledge only what I can verify using first principals.

I thought it was kind of funny because I basically said I don't give as shit what anyone else has said or done and my assessment is based on my own measuring instruments. I do not average anything nor rely on any model of anything. I measure whatever is able to be measured using any and all instrumentation available to me at the time. For example, most amateurs might use a clamp on meter while I use a magnetometer/electrometer array able to measure the rate of propagation of the magnetic/electric field within a three dimensional space.

It's not rocket science, I do not take anything for granted, everything must be proven step by step, concept by concept otherwise it means little.

AC

[SolarLab]

AC,

It's quite complex, that's why you might get a better picture using CAE.

E.G. - pulse rise/fall w.r.t inductance of the coil which depends on dv/dt,
coil physical structure; the pole material characteristics (B-H); type of
recovery cicuit; stator loading, stator material, number of winds, physical
placement; air gap between poles and stator.
Many, many, interations which are intertwined. Pulse sequencing, etc...

W.R.T.  the Investors seekin your knowledge - explain to them there is a complex
interaction within and between all the elements involved; however there are some 
good proven tools that can be used to go through the design, one elemnet at a time,
as well as interactively; to achieve good results - will take a bit of time and investment, 
but it can be done (use my initial CAE stuff if you wish, as an example - it's valid).

Hey, this stuff (analysis) is still in it's infantcy but is do-able!

Don't get bogged down with Analytics (formulas), you'll be there a hundered years 
and be no further ahead than we are now!

BTW, first principals only work when you sprincle iron filings on a paper-magnet!      

Advice - stay out-of-the-weeds! I have a scheme with this and this and this - so 
how does it work? Then, what if's...

Our brains and experience are pretty good, but not that good when 5 or more 
complex interactions are involved. Unfortunately, that's just the way it is, for me anyway! 

System engineering and analysis is pretty much all the same, be it an excess energy
device, a radio or TV, or a space borne electronic device - one piece + another piece...

Like you say, concept by concept  - but to some it is "rocket science" to others it's just a toaster!

And - don't low-ball your proposal, or yourself. A few hundred $K for success is better than a
few $K for failure - and failures are dime a dozen - successes are 1 in million (priceless)!

SL

[TommeyReed]

Snake oil salesman are on this forum, be warned!

Clearly there are investors on this forum pushing this Holcomb device, I would caution anyone putting money down on these unproven claims.

Again, nobody has a single unit that worked or still waiting on their delivery after spending 50k+.

There's a old say, " If you can't sell it to the public because it doesn't work, try to sell it to a few people with a investment return and add more snake oil to the claims". Sounds like a Dennis Lee presentation on these forums.

SL clearly sounds like the salesman, yet he has more snake oil rubbed on his hands like a car salesman waiting for a payoff. At least a Salesman has a car you can test drive, SL has nothing!

Where is the real deal Mr salesman?

I see picture, meters and claims; but no physical machine.

It's unlikely for people on this forum to not show a prototype of how something should work, Yet Mr salesman is not doing that. WHY not?

SL need to come out of the closet and explain whats in it for himself, because he clearly has nothing to show but claims of someone who can't prove free energy.

SL sounds like someone who invested a lot of $$$ on this fantasy free energy machine.

Mr Salesman, you need to explain your behavior!

Tom

[rakarskiy]

I'm wondering who the seller is here от https://holcombenergysystems.com/ ?

If you are in doubt, no one forbids you to contact Holcomb Energy System and ask to visit their research center and see for yourself. Just don't expect them to tell you the specifics of their engineering solutions. They demonstrate the work of not one, but numerous devices.

You have to be a complete fool to think that a pioneer project will not have various technical difficulties, administrative difficulties and lack of trust.

I hope they solve the technical challenges they have in scaling the plant above 200 kW.

The main issue is that this is not a forum to discuss investments and the risks involved.

As for the technical issues of how it works, I have voiced my opinion and it remains unchanged.

https://rakatskiy.blogspot.com/2022/06/overunity-holcomb-energy-system.html

Robert Holcomb's solid state synchronous machine, works on the algorithm of a traditional electromechanical synchronous machine, generating electricity. A solid state rotor is a system of electromagnets that mimic the action of a mechanical magnetic rotor. The task is to create a magnetic excitation flux, hold it and move it in the stator and rotor, synchronously inducing EMF in the generator phases. When a load is connected, the excited current in the phase wires amplifies the magnetic field of the system's magnetic flux. The magnetic flux [ϕ] has a constant component, both for a traditional electromechanical generator machine and for a Holcomb solid state machine. The Holcomb machine, like the synchronous generator, depends heavily on the connected load to create a working rotating field.

If you think that it is easy to make a setup where you can simulate the rotation of a permanent magnetic field in a stator, you are wrong. Holcomb's patent is in plain sight, but the technology in terms of materials, algorithm and calculation system is his property.


-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

https://overunity.com/17252/the-rant-room/msg505525/#msg505525

You agree, through your use of this forum, that you will not post any material which is false, defamatory, inaccurate, abusive, vulgar, hateful, harassing, obscene, profane, sexually oriented, threatening, invasive of a person's privacy, adult material, or otherwise in violation of any International or United States Federal law. You also agree not to post any copyrighted material unless you own the copyright or you have written consent from the owner of the copyrighted material. Spam, flooding, advertisements, chain letters, pyramid schemes, and solicitations are also forbidden on this forum.

[TommeyReed]

rakarskiy,

My new Tomcomb free energy generator system would do the same, looking for investor......LOL

I plan to do a series on my own version, unlike others I will have a real working prototype that everyone can copy!

"You don't have to be a rocket scientist to put hot air into a cylinder", time to start showing real stuff instead of BS!

Tom

You agree, through your use of this forum, that you will not post any material which is false, defamatory, inaccurate, abusive, vulgar, hateful, harassing, obscene, profane, sexually oriented, threatening, invasive of a person's privacy, adult material, or otherwise in violation of any International or United States Federal law. You also agree not to post any copyrighted material unless you own the copyright or you have written consent from the owner of the copyrighted material. Spam, flooding, advertisements, chain letters, pyramid schemes, and solicitations are also forbidden on this forum.