Gravity Wheel - Perpetual Motion

[hartiberlin]

It seems,
the only thing he can produce are fake videos...
what a shame...

[hydrocontrol]

Hey now..   I was not claiming the video was fake..   I was just indicating the video could be done much better to keep it from appearing fake. I was giving him the benifit of the doubt.. It is possible that it does work.. Until a better 'bulletproof' video is made I will bite my tongue..    Ow.. thats hurting. 

I see the details of his latest wheel are based on this
http://peswiki.com/index.php/OS:Scott_F._Hall:Old_Indian_Gravity_Wheel

At least this video and still picture give better details of construction. Of course that is presuming that are the same wheel.. I would have to agree with the statements made in the comment section of the link I posted above. One of those being ;

I think Scott is having fun. I think what Scott is doing is "entertainment", not news.

[TheOne]

it does not work, some try to replicate some of his device without success, its all fake

[ken_nyus]

My understanding is he is an art professor, so I think he is treating this as an art project or social experiment, or he is just having some fun.

[Pirate88179]

I am sorry but this design is not going to work.  If you look at it from the end, and I am speaking about the "burned" simple wheel from earlier, there is nothing close to "over-balance" that I can see.  It is a nice effort and his wood-working skills are good but...think about it...I actually have a working over-balance device that can withstand all examination, but I burn it because I don't like the feedback I get on the internet?  I probably would have burned it if it didn't work.  I don't buy that this ever worked on a level surface.

Bill