Working Attraction Magnet Motor on Youtube!?

[Koen1]

Don't assume it has already been proven to be a hoax because some poor slob, having nothing else to do, posts crap. Don't do this. You have no basis to assume such nonsense.

I do not. I assumed people post their mesages under their own name (or nickname), and that the post by this impostor "xpenziv" was an actual confession. I stand corrected on that one.
On top of that and as I have already stated several times, I think this specific device is not real (a "hoax" if you want to call it that) based on my own experiments with many different permanent magnet motor designs including ones very similar if not identical to this one. I feel I have more than enough basis to assume it is faked.

Also, don't hide your inability to do things behind several others (not tons of other people) who were also not able. Talent isn't distributed evenly.

I resent your belittlement of my abilities.
Every serious scientist knows arguments should be countered on an intellectual level, rather than discrediting people personally in a passive-aggressive manner.
And again I would say: put your money where your mouth is.
I have done my experiments and based on that I say this specific type of design will not work. If you insist I could build a bunch of similar and identical ones that do not work, to substantiate my statement.
If you have done any experiments with similar or identical designs that do work, then by all means post your positive results and prove me wrong! 
Either that, or stop insinuating I simply did things wrong.

[Omnibus]

No, don't impose your lack of abilities as a scientific proof of any kind. Stop that. It hasn't been proven that this cannot be built. The only thing that has been proven is that you and several others cannot build it in a working state. That counts for nothing. You shouldn't even announce it.

[Koen1]

Ah, still not built one eh?

[Golden Mean]

Hey guys and gals,

Here's a concept motor/generator I came up with that I'm building right now.  There are lots of modifications and considerations to creating a useable generator but it's a start. 

The rough idea...  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8JHb-xJGVUM

Peace,
Will

[Low-Q]

Pleas, stop this argueing. This will not lead anywhere . if it is the same motor as shown in the first place on this thread, i do believe the motor is a not- working one. It should be very easy to build a similar motor and proove if it works or not.
I have one question though: Are the magnets in the "original" motor arranged with north or south pole facing the screws, or is the magnets magnetized across the length? Maybe a replica is not working because the magnets arn't set up right?

Vidar