A machine to convert gravity to mechanical energy # 2

[brian334]

I will ask the question again. What phase of MY invention won’t work?

[broli]

I didn't went over your full design. But I commented on something similar. The part that will not work is the transfer part. At the bottom for instance the extended weight will try rock the whole thing back. Since it's too far out. Same goes for the top, but the reason is because it's too far in. So the displaced fluid doesn't affect it much.

[AB Hammer]

I will ask the question again. What phase of MY invention won’t work?

Build it and find out. For it may haunt you until you do build it. It seem like you want to be proven beyond a shadow of doubt so you may not have to build it to finalize your thoughts on the idea. I build my wheels for the very same reason. To finalize if it will work or not. So this should tell you I am talking from experience. Heck! one of my wheels spinning at about 60 RPM nearly took off my thumb ( I was trying to figure out a shifting problem and ZAP!!!) I laughed about it for it was still another step in the correct direction.

All and all the fluid movement speed is sadly a big problem for it has to move up hill.

[brian334]

Broli, if you are talking about gravity machine # 1. The momentum of the extended weight will carry it past the low spot.

[AB Hammer]

brian334

I went back and looked a little closer at you diagrams. (forgive my earlier approach) I tend to put fluid movements and buoyancy types in the same category (my point of view). Fluid movement = resistance due to the speed of the movement. Have you ever paddled a boat? Note how much force it takes to go through the fluid. Every movement encounters friction and in fluid there is allot of friction. Either it be fluid or air transfer it will still take time to do. Again you have a problem so, even if you can get it to work, it will have very little use than just a novelty.

When people are trying to get perpetual motion. They all seem to tend to try for the barely making it types. Re-do your math and try for the overwhelming types. Then if successful you will have something.