Howard Johnson Replication Tube Claim

[TinselKoala]

So why doesn't he claim my One Thousand Dollars? Can't he arrange anybody from the U. to see it? Well, I can. Just tell me where and when, and I'll have two scientists meet MyLOW to vet his device. I'll even send the Thousand Dollars Cash Money along with them, and they can give it to him on the spot.

After all, we had better hurry up before the NSA fellow comes back and re-confiscates the motor.

[CLaNZeR]

So why doesn't he claim my One Thousand Dollars? Can't he arrange anybody from the U. to see it? Well, I can. Just tell me where and when, and I'll have two scientists meet MyLOW to vet his device. I'll even send the Thousand Dollars Cash Money along with them, and they can give it to him on the spot.

After all, we had better hurry up before the NSA fellow comes back and re-confiscates the motor.

TK it not all about money mate, can you not get your head around that ? .

I have spent more than what you have offered in parts trying to replicate ideas over the years, not even counting the time, as you probably have as well.

So why do you think money will be appealing? Sorry I do not get it.

The money thing does not work for everyone on this planet, you know this. Or you just testing the water?. Think you will find even with Mylow that it is not the money thing, infact probably the last thing on his mind.

[Mannix]

There is a  story I would like to put foward here from another discussion as I remember  it  from Richard Bach ,the guy who is better known for "Jonathan Livingston seagull" it is from his book  "illusions" and illustrates the mechanisms here  well.

It is about a group of animals called "bottom feeders" They were a  group of organisms who lived on the left hand corner , on the bottom of a swirling pool near a fast flowing river somewhere. Because they stayed on the very bottom, in the left hand corner  the swirling current was not strong enough to affect them, as  they managed to get  all of their food from the very bottom. They were an ordered and an advanced society and they were happy . All of them "understood" that if they were to let go then they would have no food source and the world as they knew it would disappear and they would have no friends no family and their valued place in society would be lost for ever in the evil current. It was very easy to hang on anyway.

One day a certain bottom feeder wondered whether there was a world outside this one and he asked his friends about this. They all told him that he was not normal and perhaps they could help him understand that nobody had ever come back from letting go. . In their folklore there was an old story about somebody who came from heaven and told wonderful stories that nobody could prove. Apparently he let go and was never seen again.  So it was it was a well known FACT ! That It was not possible to let go and survive He felt Isolated for asking but he could satisfy his curiosity. The more he asked questions the more he knew that they really didn't know at all . for example what is this tail of mine for? Apparently everybody understood that their tails were from another phase of evolution and they thought him foolish for asking so silly a question. You see the bottom feeders were mostly tail, short arms a big mouth and slender arms with long fingers. One day in a fit of frustration and anger He just let go !

He watched the world that  he knew pass beneath him as he writhed in the  swirling current. He saw other animals that he had never seen before , plant material that tasted good. He came to a place where he was unable to go further and couldn't breath properly where he saw pretty pinpricks of light above and some still water just like where they lived on the bottom. He discovered that if he wriggled his tail in certain way he could get back to the bottom whenever he wanted to! Direction control was still a problem but he was working on that one.

Finally he was experiencing so many things that were new to him and really wanted to tell his people about it...he even became a little lonely and longed for the company of his kind.It was then that he noticed a group of bottom feeders like from his home on the bottom.

He wriggled his tail and landed amongst them.

They all gathered around him because they had never seen another bottom feeder before .He explained to them that he just  let go and told about other animals that looked ugly, other plants, and other bottom feeders. He showed them how to tail wriggle. The pin prick's of light were a bit much for most but he told his story well.
They were all amazed and declared him their savior and  made a special place for him every body wanted to meet him and hear about the ugly animals. He became the most talked about person.  He liked the attention, he felt happy. He didn't under stand why people followed him around though and became a bit restless again.  One day he  asked if any body would like to let go like he had. They did not understand this and started to wonder whether their savior might not be feeling well today.  He tried to show them how to wriggle their tails again and again but nobody would actually let go to see if it worked.


They all just wanted to hear the stories again , of the other ugly looking animals and other bottom feeders and even about the pinpricks of light but nobody really believed that one, they just liked the other stories so much.

Then one day, feeling a bit bored with the fact that nobody really seemed to believe the best part of his story.He Just let go again. Perhaps he could solve the direction problem this time !



So you see my friends that at some point we all fit this scenario. I am starting to wonder whether this quest to reveal Mylows's understanding will be lost in our own fear and doubt.

Our doubt's, however self justified, and whatever the cause , don't actually produce anything.   DO they?

[sterlinga]

I feel like a voice in the wilderness here. This motor as show by Mylow DOES NOT WORK!!!
Look at my youtube under excel60 and you will see there is no chance of this type of spinning action using these magnets. I know my replication is not as sophicated as Mylows but it was not necessary to do so to show the principal of working or not, I have a large and extremely well stocked shop and can produce anything at almost any level.

Hi Bill,

In my conversation with Mylow today, he said that your replication was the closest to working, of the ones he's seen (that use bar magnets).  He said he sent you several messages with suggestions.  Did you get those?

Sterling

[JohnPK]

It is time for me to throw in my 2 cents.
I certainly am not Quantum Physics major, nor an E.E.
I'm am a very good prototype machinist and have been for 30 years. I build devices like this every day for a job.
I also fly R/C/ aircraft and I build my own electric motors for them.
These motors are 3 phase A/C brushless outrunners. They weigh between 1 and 3 ounces, produce 100-1000 watts output and run up to 25,000 RPM.
I tell you this crap so you believe what I say might be true.
Mylows motors look real to me. I believe they do indeed run as he says. I have thought this from the start,
Here is my theory,
If I was to build a motor like this, I would have built it much more solid. (and it probably wouldn't work) And I bet every one of you replicators have made it much more solid. I would bet yours does not wobble and twist and shake. I believe Mylows does shake and wobble.
Can we call it resonate an oscillate?
I think getting the motor to run, might require that it is able to move about just a bit. Which is why an uneven array of magnets works. Face it, the stator stand is not heavy built at all. Those extrusions can resonate very easily. Perhaps physics can be cheated if this is why his motor is working.

Now 2 more cents. There are still those amongst us who insist on mud slinging. Please stop. I'm learning something from this thread every day. I don't want it to quit and fade away. When that happens we all quit learning.
Mylow just posted this latest most believable video less than 24 hours ago. He worked hard at it. He might be sleeping. He has a Wife, and he has a Life. Perhaps he would like to go fishing for a day, or spend a little time catching up with what ever. Give him some space, This is a lot of stuff to go through. And he does work for a living. Remember? We won't get anything out of this if our negativity scares him away.
Now the rest of us get to work and brainstorm this out. I'm sure you have all been trained what brainstorming is.

thanks..... Flame on... John