Howard Johnson Replication Tube Claim

[powercat]

Replication from rickfriedrich

Look's good

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DOO7VpOwNEM&feature=channel_page

cat

[nyctuber]

Replication from rickfriedrich

Look's good

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DOO7VpOwNEM&feature=channel_page

cat

Yep. The guy he's with is John Bedini! That's Bedini's workshop.

[TinselKoala]

Yep. The guy he's with is John Bedini! That's Bedini's workshop.

Ahh, so that's it.
I was wondering why they ignored my comments about setting up instrumental data gathering and a repeatable standardized starting method and performing some simple control experiments to compare configs--like with and without the stator present.

How do they justify shouting out "It Works!!" when it's clearly been given a strong push by Mr. Hand and it's clearly slowing down to a stop?

I mean, really, if that qualifies as "working", I should take my Minato motor and go apply for all those OU prizes...(video uploading right now, will post link when finished)
(and it's not even fake)

[xee2]

@ powercat

Replication from rickfriedrich

Thanks for the link and info.

Are those the same magnets? They don't look the same and there are only 3 of them. I don't think that is a very accurate replication.

[TinselKoala]

@ powercat

Thanks for the link and info.

Are those the same magnets? They don't look the same and there are only 3 of them. I don't think that is a very accurate replication.

Heck, why is that a problem?

Even MyLOW's recent replications haven't been very accurate replications of what he started out showing. Ten, eleven or more different configurations with all different magnets. The only things constant are the disk(s) and the bearing mount and the little stub axle thingie.
Bar magnets, horseshoe magnets, pointing in and out, up and sideways, for the rotors.
Horseshoe magnets, motor arc magnets for stators.
Widely varying numbers of rotor magnets. One stator, two stators. Fixed mount, moveable mount, adjustable mount. Close, far away. Balanced, unbalanced, symmetrical, asymmetrical. It all works, if you're Mylow.

I understand there are some good Chinese restaurants in Chicago.