Howard Johnson Replication Tube Claim

[nyctuber]

YEAH RIGHT.

I promised I would not post in this thread again, but you people are incredible.

First running presentation
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hpQA5c9guvE&fmt=18

He has the camera in his right hand.
He grabs the stator assembly with his left hand (while still holding the camera with his right hand, and starts sliding the stator assembly to the left to bring it in position.

To stop the rotation he moves the stator to the right to make the disc brake on the wood of the left stator support. If his left hand is moving the stator assembly, and his right hand isholding the camera how -pray tell - would he be moving the disc? Using his tongue?

There is NO FISHLINE visible anywhere in this video. If you see it post the frames and snapshots with highlights where, or otherwise just stop implying that there is.

Stop the negativity and stay objective.  *All of you* - You know very well who you are. If anyone rubs my nose into the fake which Video #6 is supposed to be I will fold in a heartbeat.

Next post in this thread will be a working replication.

AZ

Wrong, dude. The fishing line becomes visible at 3:56 for ~ 3 seconds, then again at 4:07 when he pans back out.

I guess you never watched the hi-res videos and don't know what to look for. The fishing line goes through the HOLE in the side of the stator mount. The HOLE is there to allow fishing line to pass through. It's been 100% debunked, you're spinning your wheels (no pun intended).

[wattsup]

I have looked at video 6 over and over and do not see any fishing line. That hole on the wooden end it a view port. Does any one have an image grab of the fishing line in video 6 or is there a hi res video 6.

[markdansie]

Hi Wattsup
I am not sure if there is a HD video number 6.....if there is I would like to see it as well.
Other than that there are some other things that have been mentioned like the sliding of the rotor unit as he did in other videos he faked.
I guess we will not know for sure. The only thing that would resolve this once and for all if someone does a working replication or Mylow shows someone how it is done so they can show the rest of us.
In the mean time this thread and others will die a natural death.
I believe the body of evidence that exists suggests he was faking all the time. Others will have a different opinion and others again will keep experimenting.
The good thing it generated a lot of interest. The bad thing it brought FE into disrepute.
If you find a hd number 6 let me know.
mark

I have looked at video 6 over and over and do not see any fishing line. That hole on the wooden end it a view port. Does any one have an image grab of the fishing line in video 6 or is there a hi res video 6.

[LightRider]

YEAH RIGHT.

I promised I would not post in this thread again, but you people are incredible.

First running presentation
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hpQA5c9guvE&fmt=18

He has the camera in his right hand.
He grabs the stator assembly with his left hand (while still holding the camera with his right hand, and starts sliding the stator assembly to the left to bring it in position.

To stop the rotation he moves the stator to the right to make the disc brake on the wood of the left stator support. If his left hand is moving the stator assembly, and his right hand isholding the camera how -pray tell - would he be moving the disc? Using his tongue?

There is NO FISHLINE visible anywhere in this video. If you see it post the frames and snapshots with highlights where, or otherwise just stop implying that there is.

Stop the negativity and stay objective.  *All of you* - You know very well who you are. If anyone rubs my nose into the fake which Video #6 is supposed to be I will fold in a heartbeat.

Next post in this thread will be a working replication.

AZ

Indeed, the analysis of the graphs leads us to ask questions about the nature of the energy that accelerates the engine. Video analysis of all the first video (especially video 41b ... but also the video 6) shows all an acceleration curve seemingly chaotic ... far from what one might expect from such an engine... and far from all last video acceleration curve... but the acceleration curve seems to always reach the same maximum ... and it seems difficult to reproduce this by hand (as demonstrated by TK). We must not forget that all first videos are zoom in, the validity of the data are thus reduced.

video#6 @9:00 zoom at the hole from one stator support... NO FISHLINE visible... as far as i can tell... (frame by frame)


video#6
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hpQA5c9guvE&fmt=18
Analysis (last videos)
http://peswiki.com/index.php/OS:MYLOW:Data:Motor_RPM_--_by_LightRider
Analysis (first videos)
http://peswiki.com/index.php/OS:MYLOW:Data#Speed_Graph_from_April_3_Video

LightRider

[TinselKoala]

I have looked at video 6 over and over and do not see any fishing line. That hole on the wooden end it a view port. Does any one have an image grab of the fishing line in video 6 or is there a hi res video 6.

You know you'll never believe something somebody sends you.

Look at the YT video in the link
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hpQA5c9guvE&fmt=18
Watch in Highdef. Don't blow up to full screen.
Imagine where the hole is in the left stator support. Now watch 3:53- 3:58.
If you don't see it you need new glasses, or a new monitor.

A slightly loose string, coupled with the effect of the knot sliding over the support hole edge as the knot slides past it, might make the rotation rate signature look "chaotic" yet still allow the consistent max rpms.