Howard Johnson Replication Tube Claim

[ALFPARTS]

I believe everyone that is so sure it isn't working is looking at the effect of the magnets only.

If you consider the effect of the aluminum plate and understand the field retention and delay caused by the field moving through this plate,...... ah never mind, this involves thinking and it's much easier to just say it must be fake.

After 150 years, the pool of reasons why this can't work is very large and easy for any idiot to pull from, but very few can pull from the tiny pool of reasons why it could work.

And yet you have to rely on what others say because you either will not or cannot provide any technical foundation from your own intellect? I see where where you are not headed with you logic. If you are going to make comments you are expected to expand beyond the point of providing no foundation whatsoever. I am not saying that you are or may be incorrect about you assertions. It's just reasonable to ask that you make a case for your claims. This productive members of this forum are not obliged to explain themselves to anyone.

[billmehess]

It's real, it's fake, it's real, it's fake. This can go on forever. Why do all the people who say the device works not understand that unless there is verification then logic MUST dictate that this "motor" is not valid.
Mylow posts video after video on Youtube to convince everyone that he is legit but all he has to do is show it to Sterling or PPMtester or anyone, this would clear everything up immed. Does he do this? No and it looks like he really never will.
I just went and saw the new Star Trek (great movie) but all I saw were fantastic special effects on the screen. Based on this do I believe it's for real-I hope not.
In the final analysis youtube videos mean nothing. Why is every member of this forum not screaming for verification? I would like to see him running the device on a driveway, in a park on a picnic table anywhere but this "highly controlled" setting where the device is being shown.
This has become such a simple build there should be a dozen replications in the next 24 hrs.His supporters keep saying that he does not have to proof anything that his videos do that for him , this is nuts. He must prove it and standby every claim he makes.
Let me ask every member of this forum who believes this to be a running motor , if you wanted to absolutely prove your point would you not immed. be showing the device running to every person, news agency and anyone else you could ? He makes no sense at all.

[hartiberlin]

Hi Bill,
maybe José just wants to go on with his normal  live and does
not want to stand in the spotlight !?

Maybe he is just telling and teaching us in his videos how it is done
and waits for some replicators to verify him and then
the replicators can go public ?

Could be a logical assumption.

Maybe he wants just to live on his normal day job live ?

[billmehess]

He loves the spot light, that's why he is doing all these videos. He is basking in the limelight of confusion and misdirection. FBI, MIB's, Lawyers, NSA etc. If he did not love the drama he is creating he would simply allow the device to be examined and then he could (if he really wanted to) fade into the shadows. How may more videos 20 or 30 is there no end?
He says he has a motor that could change the world but refuses to show it to anyone.
Again there is no logic here. In a week or so this will all be history as there will most likely be no replications of this very simple device. Hopefully by then his army of supporters will realize the truth of the situation.
Mylow, according to Sterling you read all these posts what are you hiding?

[dixiepnum]

@bill,

i can't speak for your motivations, and you can't speak for mylow's...what's so hard to understand or accept about that?

I gave up on mylow following the rules of science and project management about 2 months ago.....

who cares? really....

it's 50% entertainment, and 50% world-saving-technology...

mylow will get there in his own mysterious ways...or would you prefer that we scare him away with our urgent requests to get into a secure lab? maybe then he'll disappear....

do you want him to disappear? I don't...

this thing will evolve....it's all mushy mushy, but let this flower grow how it wants to for a while....

eventually, it will start walking and talking like a duck...

sorry for sounding so fudgy-liberal-artsy-fartsy!