Howard Johnson Replication Tube Claim

[TinselKoala]

I did not read the recent posts they move so fast so I'll read them after this post.

@TK

Don't move anything. I did not see your foot go over the strings. lol

No seriously can you blame me for asking since you have everything there already so here is my last request. Do the same thing but remove the pulley from the motor and make it turn just with the shaft and at one moment, if the wheel turns and holds the string straight enough, stop the wheel. You can secure the motor with something but don't.

Yes I know I am a pain in the ass but here is the deal. This has to be shown as in Mylows videos. I would ask you to then consider doing all this, then removing the string from the wheel base, placing it on the table expecting it to stay in place.

Man, don't you get it yet. There is not only a wheel turning, there is a whole series of wheel manipulations that he did while having all this around him to be accessible. I just want to see if you leave that string off the wheel, what happens to it on the shaft side. Does the looseness make the string unwind off the shaft. Did we see Mylow going to the sofa to do anything. No.

Incredible theories require incredible proof. If you and I were in forensics (Hmm maybe a new business), we would not expect any less from lab trials.

But you got me so far on the running theory being feasible at this stage. There are still point that I brought up that have not been addressed yet and these would have to be addressed. Running with a string proves it is possible but it does not prove it did. Man am I getting tired of this or what.

With the timing capacitors I currently (pun!) have installed in the stepper driver, the wheel will be turning slowly if I don't use the pulley. But I assure you I can do as you request. Do I have to? I mean, I'm not even getting a free lunch out of this. And I AM hungry.

(And didn't I show, in the first video with the black thread, just what you are asking for here? I just used the motor shaft in that one, didn't I?)

"Incredible theories require incredible proof. If you and I were in forensics (Hmm maybe a new business), we would not expect any less from lab trials."

So why do we expect so much less from Mylow, before we go off and spend a bunch of money on parts?

[Bobbotov]

So why do we expect so much less from Mylow, before we go off and spend a bunch of money on parts?

Well, Sterling had posted that as one of the requirements for winning the replication prize that the replicator's device be inspected by a third party. Something that he never required for Mylow's despite many who called for it and which would have put this whole saga to rest very quickly. So yes, much less is expected from Mylow apparently.

[joe_1001101]

Ahh, it's crazy glue, that's all I wanted to know, thanks for the info, don't have here in the UK.

I thought you maybe referring to the holes in each side of the stator mounts.  Possible fish line access?  Can't tell if there is a hole in that aluminum plate on the one stator side.  Anyone see?

Joe

[Bobbotov]

Double post. Server choked on a fish bone perhaps.

[RunningBare]

As far as I am aware, there is no high resolution video for that one, it would be impossible to pick out anything positive or negative.

I thought you maybe referring to the holes in each side of the stator mounts.  Possible fish line access?  Can't tell if there is a hole in that aluminum plate on the one stator side.  Anyone see?

Joe