MylowHJ Replication - Discussion

[TinselKoala]

TK
Sir
What specific truth[being suppressed ] are you talking about?
Chet

You'll have to ask wattsup--he deleted the post I made, right after LostCause's nice long post.
I think I may have pointed out that a thousand dollars cash will buy a lot of cat food and bird seed.
But there were some other truths in there too.

@wattsup: Go ahead. Replace all instances of "Mylow" with "TK" and I will be glad to address each and every case. For one thing, if I actually had something that behaved like Mylow's wheel, for the reasons he says it does, I would take TK's money in a heartbeat, just to see him eat crow and shut up.
Wouldn't you?

(And, if you will only recall correctly, it was Mylow who first involved his cat, his bird, and his wife in this topic. Since he brought them in, I say they are fair game. Could you, just for the record, quote a "pot shot" I took at them, so the rest of us will know what to avoid?)

[newbie123]

How many people have bought his plans, and attempted a replication?

The truth that there good reason to doubt MyLow's invention.

There really seems to be a lot of reliance on faith, which is very unscientific.  An amateur claims to violate a well-established, basic, law of physics with an invention so simple that surely, if that invention was capable of violating the laws of physics, someone would have done it already.

The response from the youtube community (aka your average person) is "not likely," as it should be.  The response from actual scientists, well there is none, because a real scientist would not devote 5 seconds of time to this crap.  But here it's like people are rallying behind this guy, when all we have is videos.  Not a single replication.

I do not know if you have ever seen magic on TV, but do you think it's really magic, or there is some trick?

I think this is strange too...  In reality, people have absolutely no scientific reason to believe this guy's claims UNLESS they have seen it working in person, or replicated his experiment themselves...        People are going by this logic...   "He seems like an honest guy, therefore he must be telling the truth"      and even...  "The MIBs tried to interfere with his experiments, therefore he must be telling the truth!"  ...  This is just weird!   

There is a  (small) chance his magnetic motor works, and might not be in any violation any known physics laws... Or it could work and be utilizing new physics..   But until I see a few independent working replications I will have serious doubts.      I'm always extra skeptical about people trying to profit from their designs designs (who talk about MIBs, etc)..  Especially when nobody has produced a working replication!

[Omega_0]

Someone's replication, just a start:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j89GaFDnllk

[Omega_0]

The stator magnet is easily available and it goes by the name of Arc Magnet for motors.

Example:
http://www.made-in-china.com/china-products/productviewkqDxuVsbrgcZ/Arc-Ferrite-Magnets-for-PMDC-Motors-Y10T-20-.html

More:
http://images.google.com/images?q=arc+motor+magnet&btnG=Search+Images

[Justalabrat]

The stator magnet is easily available and it goes by the name of Arc Magnet for motors.

In these videos Mylow talks about the magnets obtained from the DC motor.

This video shows it the first time, but says its not magnetized the right way:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dXaaw63l520&feature=channel_page#t=08m45s

This video shows it mounted on the stator arm and it's been re-magnetized the right way:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xm-oVrVBRGY&feature=channel_page#t=03m40s