Thane Heins Perepiteia Replications

[CRANKYpants]

I'm free to say and express whatever I want. Just like you.

TRUE - YOU CAN BE AS WRONG AS YOU WISH.
AND YOU CAN BE A SLEAZY DOG BY CHANGING THE TITLE OF THE THREAD TO SUIT YOUR OWN DISINGENUOUS STYLE AS WELL.

And everybody else is free to do their own experiments which will either verify your interpretations of the effect or find query with it.

TRUE BUT THE EXPERIMENTS HAVE TO BE DONE CORRECTLY.

Let the replicators make up their own minds!

RIGHT - YOU SHOULD TRY IT.

Try feeling free to let others express themselves without your derision or brow beating.

NOPE - A PERSON WHO CANNOT FOLLOW INSTRUCTIONS CORRECTLY - CAN'T PRODUCE VALID RESULTS AND A PERSON WHO CAN'T PRODUCE VALID RESULTS REQUIRES CORRECTION - IF THIS IS TO BE A THANE HEINS PEREPITEIA THREAD.

IF IT IS MEANT TO BE AN AD-HOC THROW A BUNCH OF CRAP TOGETHER AND HOPE IT WORKS THREAD OR A LET'S SCREW IT UP SO WE CAN SLAM IT THREAD THEN SO-BE-IT.

Democracy is a wonderful thing. It only exists when we are free to disagree, without coercion to agree, nor comdemnation if we disagree.

WRONG AGAIN - CONDEMNATION IS PART OF IT - BUT NUMBERS AND DATA DON'T LIE ONLY PEOPLE DO.

THAT IS WHY I GO TO GREAT LENGTHS TO POST PHOTO DATA OR VIDEO AND EVERYTHING IS DOUBLE OR TRIPLE CHECKED BY OTHERS.

T

[i_ron]

BUT NUMBERS AND DATA DON'T LIE ONLY PEOPLE DO.
T

I AM ONLY HERE TO ASSIST OTHERS AND I ONLY CAME BACK TO REDIRECT A REPLICATOR BACK ON COURSE

What that means translated: if the list had been left alone the fallacy of the Perepiteia generator would have been exposed.

- I AM NOT HERE TO BE INSTRUCTED ON THE OBVIOUS.

Indeed, if your theory is wrong you will not admit it, correct it, nor apologize to those you have belittled in your “claim” that they are wrong.
Just a steady diet of innuendo and character assassination. 

“In my personal experience” I did the test on the E core and showed it to be a fallacy. You have not shown any evidence that my conclusion is wrong, Read my post again, my data does not lie.
The E core is a hoax!

Ron

[CRANKYpants]

AS I SAID JADED AND CYNICAL.

I HAVE CORRECTED THE THEORY TWICE SO FAR.

T

[LarryC]

EXPERIMENTS HAVE TO BE DONE CORRECTLY.

A PERSON WHO CANNOT FOLLOW INSTRUCTIONS CORRECTLY - CAN'T PRODUCE VALID RESULTS AND A PERSON WHO CAN'T PRODUCE VALID RESULTS REQUIRES CORRECTION - IF THIS IS TO BE A THANE HEINS PEREPITEIA THREAD.

These are key points, but the fact is the instructions are not clearly stated in one location. There are pieces in various post along with tons of BS post in between. For anybody to go thru and not get lost in the manure and various stages and then create a working replication is amazing. The videos have good performance information but not detailed replication information. 

You need to have a thread where the first post contains the how to instructions (like Luc's) and any new people wanting to replicate can go there and get it replicated quickly.

Even show various build material that worked, for instance my cores (like your originals) were made from various widths of 1/8 thick steel bars from Home Depot, which were much much cheaper.

I'm sure this would cut down the BS from those people doing it just to distract or mislead. I don't think this is true for all dissenting opinions, so those will still exist, but more manageable.

It should significantly cut down on the incorrect replications and people claiming it is a hoax.

If you don't like the first post method, at least add the build detail to the board or to the post when you list the video.

Regards, Larry

   

[i_ron]

AS I SAID JADED AND CYNICAL.

T

It was my request to Stefan that started this list. I am in charge here.
I will not tolerate any further abuse from you. You are a guest on this list along with all the rest of us. Please refrain from such talk.

If you don't like it you have the option of reactivating your old list.

Ron