New permanent magnet motor on youtube from Roobert33

[Qwert]

but this isn't a four-stroke ICE... and not all engines need flywheels.

Right! It's not ICE. And your argumentation is not backed by real experiments, it's just theorization. That's why modern science is always backed by real experiments. Anyway, to my knowledge no ICE exists without flywheel; even Wankel has one.

[WilbyInebriated]

Right! It's not ICE. And your argumentation is not backed by real experiments, it's just theorization. That's why modern science is always backed by real experiments. Anyway, to my knowledge no ICE exists without flywheel; even Wankel has one.

so what's your point? this vgate thing is not a 4stroke ICE... it's not even similar.
ok, so to your knowledge no ICE exist without a flywheel, so what... is this vgate thing an ICE? there are other piston engines that do exist and do run without a flywheel. here is some experimentation to back my argument...
http://home.ctlnet.com/~robotguy67/classic_cars/air_engines/V-Twin/air_engines.htm
you can post your mea culpa anytime.

even wankel... oooohh.

[ramset]

QWert
I agree, calloway has to be where Robertto started on his trip to madness!
Seems like it should work!

We loose experimenters all the time this way!
They Go nuts!
I really can't blame them ,The little gray cells get soft!

A consequence of seeking OU.
We've seen this before and we'll see it again!
Maybe we should start a 12 step group for some of these poor addicted souls?

I know what I want for Christmas
A "calloway" !!
Gotta try it!!

Chet

[Qwert]

even wankel... oooohh.

My point is, that you can't say anything for sure until you make a real experiment on real subject. And your behaviour guys, is theorization only. I believe that you know that there are some examples in real world where something works against rationality or against human judgement.
Pneumatic motor is not an ICE and not an engine; it works on already energized air, like electric motor works on previously created electric current. Also a "motor" cannot be called an "engine" since "engine" always resembles a generator and "motor" never. And this kind of machine (Roobert's) can be called a generator since it does not rely on earlier created energy. That's why I compare it rather to the ICE and not to the "electric motor".
Modified:
And why four-stroke ICE? With human rationality it should not work since three strokes of four are idle, even worse, one of those three is "compression": in fact, it would not work without energy conserving flywheel.

[ramset]

Stephan,
PLease ask Roberto to come here!
Tell him we understand!!

Some of your friends would like to play with his idea!!
Or just send us a PDF on what he has done to date!

You have to at least ask him!!
For Christmas 

Chet