quentron.com

[MarkE]

Wikipedia doesn't back my assertion that the fully charged capacitor will leak @mark E? Wikipedia backs my assertion that the fully charged capacitor in THAT or any diagram will leak mr E.your saying that it will hold its charge permanently.your saying that when that switch is open NO leakage whatsoever will occur.I don't believe you @mark E.

You claim to have an example of a fully reversible thermodynamic process.  You[ve have done nothing to show that you actually do. It's pretty sad for you when you resort to fabricating statements I never made.

[profitis]

You've done nothing to show that I don't.something for the audience to ponder @mark E.why don't you rather admit that you can't bust this thought experiment and we can close the case.I see in other threads your too happy when thought experiments come your way.why not this one? This one only requires you to show zero leakage accross a simple capacitor.you'd think that would be chopsticks for a scientist.

[MarkE]

You've done nothing to show that I don't.something for the audience to ponder @mark E.why don't you rather admit that you can't bust this thought experiment and we can close the case.I see in other threads your too happy when thought experiments come your way.why not this one? This one only requires you to show zero leakage accross a simple capacitor.you'd think that would be chopsticks for a scientist.

Round and round we go.  You've done this many times now.  The burden of proof for an extraordinary claim, such as your claim that you have an example of a fully reversible thermodynamic process, is upon the claimant.  You have not even begun to make an argument for your claim.  You have shadow boxed yourself black and blue.

[profitis]

Its a thought experiment @mark E.don't take it too seriously.

[Philip Hardcastle]

Hi profitis,


I can assure you that your position on the thought experiment is wrong, and I can in detail explain why (this is one of my fields of expertise), but being respectful to the participants in the conversation I will properly give MarkE the opportunity of meeting your challenge, if after giving him a few more days he still cannot explain the reasons that it is false, then I will.


Phil