KARPEN PILE

[MarkE]

Right yes.now imagine what a cm3 is going to do.that first scopeshot illustrates clearly the selfcharging capabilities of the gadget.take a rest pomodoro we need to discuss things

It shows that a cell that is continuously supplied with feed stock repolarizes after being loaded down.  The tests with the "secret electrode" should give you pause.  Do they simply reflect in an accelerated time frame what is going to happen with the Ag electrode?

[profitis]

Lol so tell us what's going to be 'usedup' in a sealed system then mark E.its a karpen cell,how long do you expect it to last?

[profitis]

If I knew what the dud electrode material was then I could tell you straight why it failed

[pomodoro]

The secret electrode was graphite

[MarkE]

Lol so tell us what's going to be 'usedup' in a sealed system then mark E.its a karpen cell,how long do you expect it to last?

You claim to be an electrochemist?  Really?  You have a cell, feed stock in the form of hydrogen is continuously admitted to the cell during the experiment and you assert that the system is closed?  Really?

The experiment makes no attempt to assay materials after it has run.  As an alleged practicing professional, on what basis do you claim that there is evidence that oxidation / reduction did not take place within the cell?  Or alternatively that electrons could move through the external circuit without oxidation/reduction taking place in the cell?  What do you claim that pomodoro's very nice experiment shows that is out of the ordinary?