Is there any mechanic devide that works?

[conradelektro]

The person who made the discussed video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YreCJDvIX2Q had enough time since last September to follow up wit a bigger or better version or to become famous with his perpetuate machine.

Since nothing has happened, I guess it is a strange hoax. Of course, I can never be sure (and this is exactly the intention of such a hoax).

Greetings, Conrad

[ayeaye]

The person who made the discussed video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YreCJDvIX2Q had enough time since last September to follow up wit a bigger or better version or to become famous with his perpetuate machine.

This is again that assumption that one supposed to become famous when one makes some great invention. As i said, this is not necessarily true. This has already been said here before, the Nobel prize. Have you heard anything about famous writers, who died in poverty, and became famous only after their death? This is how it is, the society is not necessarily always fair, and there is no logical reason why it always has to be.

Saying that, i don't mean anything about whether his device does or does not work. I put these things into a category of unknown, until there is no convincing explanation why they should work, i think they are not worth the effort. Or if some think that they are worth the effort, then what you can do is to write a good explanation of why they should work. Because like for me, this concept of point and flat electrodes, and what they should do, is absolutely strange, and i just simply cannot think much about it.

I understand that some shape may enable to hold more charge than another shape. i see some imbalance there, and the idea is clever, but i know nothing convincing there that makes all that possible. One thing, the charges in a metal are very weak as much as i know, they cannot be compared to the charges in the Wimshurst machine, where they are like in a capacitor. Even for that alone reason that experiment is not convincing at all. And it is also not replicated.

[Low-Q]

The person who made the discussed video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YreCJDvIX2Q had enough time since last September to follow up wit a bigger or better version or to become famous with his perpetuate machine.

Since nothing has happened, I guess it is a strange hoax. Of course, I can never be sure (and this is exactly the intention of such a hoax).

Greetings, Conrad

Very classic. The only perpetual is that people will never stop trying to do the impossible. I wonder why they're not harvesting the free energy that is right there before their eyes. Sun, wind, water falls.


Vidar

[ayeaye]

Well, the overunity is nature too.

[Low-Q]

Well, the overunity is nature too.

No. There is no overunity in nature. If that was the case, we would observe an energy feedback that increased in magnitude for ever. Imagine that energy and mass increase 100% every 1 billion years, we would observe a radiation and mass that is approx 16 000 times greater than it actually is. The sun during its 5 billion year existence would be 30 times brighter than it is today. The earth would be 16 times larger etc. What we do know is that the energy balance in the universe is pretty much balanced on a constant value.


If overunity exist, it must also apply to mass - not only energy.


Vidar