Successful TPU-ECD replication !

[giantkiller]

@HopeForHumanity ,
Doesn't it make you think though?

--giantkiller.

[HopeForHumanity]

@giantkiller,

It gives me two thoughts. It does question sm's intentions, but many have seen too many strange things happening when trying to replicate the device, and if he was already getting away with it then he would not waste time to reply to emails and give any information to mannix. The email doesn't make sense in a way that it claims he does all this stuff and gets away with it, but it creates the question why does he even give clues if he is doing fine "scamming". Thats why I don't really care about what the email says. The other thought that comes to mind, just how many people want to put down steven mark. The email doesn't really have any links to information examples emails or any conclusive evidence that steven mark is a scammer.

[Ergo]

I and others have repeatedly called for Otto and Roberto to carry out some proper tests to establish the true power consumption of the device when powering the lamp load. They know the importance of doing this if nothing else but to confirm to themeselves that it is more than induction lighting their lamp. Their documentation is very good but unfortunately lacks this vital information.

Clive

Which of course is one of the most typical signs of energy scammers.
Have a look at #9 of this link. http://amasci.com/freenrg/fnrg.html

Quote:
The inventor doesn't publish successful scientific research papers (i.e. he doesn't publish detailed replication instructions,)
or if he does, other researchers can't get them to work. Something vital wasn't included.

[ronotte]

Hey Ergo,

don't you dare to say thinghs like that you have posted in this thread:

I DON'T WANT MONEY FROM ANYBODY I NEVER ASKED

what I did has been an original effort to help everybody interested and is all that I actually know!

So in my opinion people like you should be banned to write in this Forum.

Roberto

[Earl]

@clive, @ergo

did it ever occur to you that your beloved link
http://amasci.com/freenrg/fnrg.html

only concerns inventors/researchers asking for money?

Do you understand this?  YES or NO?

Neither Roberto nor Otto have ever asked for money.

Neither Roberto nor Otto is doing this so that clive and ergo can show their agressive impatience of basic research.

Do you understand that you have no rights of any shape or form to expect something from them?  YES or NO?
They are not asking anything from you, what right to you have to ask anything from them?

Do you fully understand the following quotes:

"Basic research is when I'm doing what I don't know what I'm doing!"  Wernher von Braun

"If I knew what I was doing, I would not call it research."  Albert Einstein

Roberto and Otto are doing basic research in an area where there are no maps or charts.
They are not presenting a comercial product, nor are they asking anyone for money.
Nor are either making any claims of excess energy.  The topic title was a bit over optimistic, that is all.

If it really is only traditional induction that is lighting their lamps, they will some day realize this and publicize it.  Criticism is only welcome if it is positive and constructive and takes into account that hobby researchers have jobs and family and resource limits to consider.

It seems to me that this is a good opportunity for both Clive and Ergo to keep their egoistic mouths shut.  And that is putting it in a very diplomatic manner.

If either of you persist in directly or indirectly accussing Roberto or Otto of scamming someone out of money, I will ask Harti to put you on read-only.

Earl

I and others have repeatedly called for Otto and Roberto to carry out some proper tests to establish the true power consumption of the device when powering the lamp load. They know the importance of doing this if nothing else but to confirm to themeselves that it is more than induction lighting their lamp. Their documentation is very good but unfortunately lacks this vital information.
Clive

Which of course is one of the most typical signs of energy scammers.
Have a look at #9 of this link. http://amasci.com/freenrg/fnrg.html
Quote:
The inventor doesn't publish successful scientific research papers (i.e. he doesn't publish detailed replication instructions,)
or if he does, other researchers can't get them to work. Something vital wasn't included.