Is Lindsay?s ?SM? a fraud?

[innovation_station]

@all i liked everyones work .....

marco i liked your last build so i did it my way not done yet tho ....

it looks to me like a pluse motor with the rotation subbed for a generation coil ... 


yep this brut will have 6 coils will work with the 6pac and i will sub a generation picup coil or 2  for the rotor 

ps im useing wood ... and my coils are polorazied bifiller 2000 turns per coil so a total of 12000 turns thease are my electro mags only!!

the center collector wich consists of short pices of copper wire woven in and out of my electro magnets will connect to the final wrap if i use gargen wire mixed with my center collector it should be contained if i do not use it ther i will put it on the outter wrap ...   some where it will be there ...

a pic when i finally finish winding got 2 done ...


ist

[Grumpy]

"Then there is the claim that the US Navy has had a similar device since the 1950's - this from a very good source.  I do not doubt this at all."

Nor do i this could have been replicated from around 1930 using relative simple sinewave technology and tube amps.  Its cousin is the hendershot device.

Yeah Yeah Yeah

Ever seen a replication of a Hendershot device?  Thought not.

I don't know how familiar you are with Tesla's work, but he equated impulses to a jackhammer.  His magical feats were not produced with his magnifier but with his three-phase rotating spark gap - which he stated was not used for wireless transmission of energy.

Anyway, you can stick with your sine waves as they can also be made to work.  When you bias above zero - it all kinda looks the same...

[Mannix]

You keep telling me you cant make rotating magnetic field yet this circuit does exactly that. The L's are your control coils which are the grids in your cold triode. The big loop is the collector this should be LC with a cap on the output.

OR use a 3 phase driver which in effect is a single oscillator with phase shifted outputs. Both will give magnetic rotation.

Bolt,
the collector is a bit confusing as it looks like a short in the loop
Could you tell us how many turns would be used for your example of 60 hz?

Thanks

[BEP]

You keep telling me you cant make rotating magnetic field yet this circuit does exactly that. The L's are your control coils which are the grids in your cold triode. The big loop is the collector this should be LC with a cap on the output.

OR use a 3 phase driver which in effect is a single oscillator with phase shifted outputs. Both will give magnetic rotation.

In your example and any generator or motor used today the only thing that rotates is the rotor. The focus of the magnetic flux is simply being moved from one point to another. It is not turning. This may be exactly what is required. I am not one to say if it is or not. However, the magnetic field is not rotating. You cannot rotate the measurement of something and proclaim you are rotating the item under measurement.

If I make the statement I am rotating a magnetic field it is no more correct than if I spin on the toes of one foot and tell everyone I am rotating the world around me. It isn't me that is spinning - it is the world! Now that is classic 2D thinking.

Sorry, but I've tried to find the means to make it happen for decades. After all that time I realized even if I could make one spin it would make no difference at all. Why? Because field lines are also B.S. They simply do not exist unless you add material between the poles of a magnet. These lines crossing a wire are supposed to be the reason for induction.
Also B.S. Induction isn't lines crossing a wire it is variations in flux density over a wire.
The use of 'lines' was created so those with minimal abstract thought abilities could visualize the effect. The latter statement is a matter of historic record.

For those that think they can rotate a magnetic field, magnetic flux is generated by a magnet or coil, field lines/layers or laminations are the normal makeup of magnetic flux, I am sorry. Your opinion will likely never change so I'll leave you to your travels.

You folks ever play 'Whack-a-Mole' ? That is the vision I have when I see discussions about pounding one coil after another in their attempts to cause movement. Things do appear to move. My opinion is they aren't moving the way you think.

In the end the most important thing is you choose your own direction and do it with gusto. Having a little fun while learning something new is also a great plus  

[bolt]

"Bolt,
the collector is a bit confusing as it looks like a short in the loop
Could you tell us how many turns would be used for your example of 60 hz?"


DONT run this on the mains supply its only a 3 phase schematic. Use signal generator only. The circle is the motor body and you must not copy verbatim so ignore the circle connections. In reality you make say 50 turns of heavy speaker or stranded mains cable for the collector and put a poly AC cap across the ends. The L's are suggested  20 turns of thin stranded wire like door bell wire wrapped around the collector 120 degrees apart. The 36uF cap must be AC cap but you must find this value to run resonance. By using big C's values start by trying to get this to run down at say 20 Hz so you can see compass rotate. You can try wiring the 3 coils in Delta as well as Y.

Remember this is ONLY half the dipole till you make two and stack them you will never get kicks or volts anywhere its for proof of concept only. The final frequncy to get a fast enough spin with 2 of these stacked and start to see odds things happening could be 500k to 1 meg Hz from your sig gen with the right (smaller) caps all tuned in perfect resonance.

Wiki =A symmetric rotating magnetic field can be produced with as little as three coils. The three coils will have to be driven by a symmetric 3-phase AC sine current system, thus each phase will be shifted 120 degrees in phase from the others. For the purpose of this example, the magnetic field is taken to be the linear function of the coil's current.

What im trying here to show that an RV modified motor concept can make a virtual 3 phase rotation from a single phase.