Howard Johnson Replication Tube Claim

[chrisC]

Chase212327

The point is there is no replication to be made. I do not know you personally, and I'm not flaming you, but you are contributing to this nonsense, please would you honestly comment on the last Mylow video in the context of this whole thread? P.S. I have actually built something and posted the results honestly if you would care to look.

@HiggsField

I don't think you should vent your frustrations and negative opinions in this manner. All Chase212327 did was to try to reason with the crowd of replicators than in order to prove Mylow's experiment, people need to do the right thing, ie compare apples with apples. I don't think that's unreasonable.

If at the end of the day, replicators did their job based on exacting (or closest) comparisons, then MyLow needs to prove he's true or be forever condemned as a FAKE!

Peace.

cheers
chrisC

[Pirate88179]

chrisC:

Well said.

Bill

[Chase212327]

HiggsField,
RE:  "...you are contributing to this nonsense..."
I honestly don't believe I am.  My intent is to provide assistance with a true replication effort, to either prove or disprove the concept.  I am assuming nothing at this point.  I think a scientific approach to replicating is in order, and has not been attempted by anyone (because the exact magnet set is no longer available).  Then, sloppy attempts and failures are fodder for critics to attack anyone trying to assist with a true replicate (prove or disprove).  I'm not one to taking anything on face value, THAT is why I want to see somone try to use reasonable tolerances to prove or disprove this claim.  I'm not going to take Mylow's videos as proof.

Chase212327

Chase212327

The point is there is no replication to be made. I do not know you personally, and I'm not flaming you, but you are contributing to this nonsense, please would you honestly comment on the last Mylow video in the context of this whole thread? P.S. I have actually built something and posted the results honestly if you would care to look.

[HiggsField]

@nyctuber

"God is a concept"... I'm not sure what point your making here. 90%+ of engineers and physicists are atheists.  It your advocating blind faith then please please press on!

[HiggsField]

@Chase212327

You're obviously missing something here, else you would not have replied to my obviously provocative post. The whole thing started with with a  lie. What is there too replicated? Nothing!