Quote from: profitis on March 30, 2015, 07:00:19 AM
I)socrates is a man.all men are mortal
II)Socrates is mortal. Does this argument have any assumptions in it

Only the author of the argument can tell you if they are making an assumption.  In one case you said

Quote from: profitis on March 28, 2015, 10:58:44 AM
I)Assuming all equilibrium gas over and underpotentials are dependant on different elemental constants

and in another

Quote from: profitis on March 29, 2015, 10:41:42 PM
I)all equilibrium gas over and underpotentials are dependant on different elemental constants

To help you out you might want to ask yourself this question:

Do I have elements in my argument which are not proved in the argument itself?

The best part of all of this is how much profitis thinks he's being clever. 

Sarkeizen:'Only the author of the argument can tell you if they are making an assumption.'

Is it compulsory for the author of an argument to tell the counter-arguer wether his/her argument contains assumption when asked by the counter-arguer if his/her argument contains assumption

Sarkeizen:'Do I have elements in my argument which are not proved in the argument itself?'

Is it possible to have such an argument and can you give an example of such an argument

Quote from: profitis on March 30, 2015, 08:40:50 AM
Is it compulsory for the author of an argument to tell the counter-arguer wether his/her argument contains assumption

LOL.  Ask yourself this:  In this context, that is you are claiming you can PROVIDE a written argument which makes some point.  Can you achieve that if you do not disclose all the necessary parts of your argument?

For example *words* are a necessary part of your argument.  Can you provide a written argument that does not use words?

If profits danced any more this place would turn into a disco.

Sarkeizen:'For example *words* are a necessary part of your argument.  Can you provide a written argument that does not use words?'

Can you? Give an example and I'l adjust if necessary.teach me how to put you in a corner on your terms