Friedrich Luling Magnet Motor

[nix85]

Yes this is soo true. That is why I named the parts in my Frame pics.
To be honest, I can't even follow you what you mean by U-Plate.

I mean the plate with square hole in the middle between rotor and oscillating bar.

What makes you think this? In fact, on my testings the Iron bar dropped as soon as I put the upper bar on top.
It was still attached, but it was totally separated with a very light touch. So I would guess, it is a bit like Ufos rig.

I have not seen your test so i have no idea what exactly you mean.

You will best answer my question if you say, which part of the stator is in your opinion a magnet and how come rotor does not stick to it as it glides by it totally effortlessly during 3 turns (linked with timing above).

[Ufopolitics]

Ok so even by leaving the repulsion side out, the back stroke will cause a rotation, but its direction is undefined. Got it.

No, Semi, I edited my answer...


If you take off the repulsion side at stator...Neutralization is gone, so the attraction side increases to max values, I doubt there would be enough force on Piston to separate those two magnets at the gap it does when repulsion stator side is present.


I have not done that test ...however, I know how it works if even the repulse side air gap is spread too much...




Regards




Ufopolitics

[Semi]

No, Semi, I edited my answer...
If you take off the repulsion side at stator...Neutralization is gone, so the attraction side increases to max values, I doubt there would be enough force on Piston to separate those two magnets at the gap it does when repulsion stator side is present.
I have not done that test ...however, I know how it works if even the repulse side air gap is spread too much...

Yeah I know, this is not about having your rig running with the Neutralisation gone. I've just observed that behaviour on my
test rig, and I was wondering how yours would act. If you find the time to test this, would be nice to know.

I mean the plate with square hole in the middle between rotor and oscillating bar.

I have not seen your test so i have no idea what exactly you mean.

You will best answer my question if you say, which part of the stator is in your opinion a magnet and how come rotor does not stick to it as it glides by it totally effortlessly during 3 turns (linked with timing above).

True I am sorry. I need to put those pics on that page as well.

Using my Terms from the Frame 1892
https://s-em-i.github.io/s-em-i.github.io-SecretsOfLueling/Frames/1892.jpeg
https://s-em-i.github.io/s-em-i.github.io-SecretsOfLueling/Frames/1892_Marked.jpeg

It seems most likely to me that the 1st and 3rd Block are the Magnets.

And as you can see in your linked Video, the upper and lower arc are resting on these blocks. So the armature can pass.
This is Mr. Lülings neutralised stage as I conclude.
It feels like I am repeating my self. You can PM me, so we don't litter this thread too much.

[nix85]

True I am sorry. I need to put those pics on that page as well.

Using my Terms from the Frame 1892
https://s-em-i.github.io/s-em-i.github.io-SecretsOfLueling/Frames/1892.jpeg
https://s-em-i.github.io/s-em-i.github.io-SecretsOfLueling/Frames/1892_Marked.jpeg

It seems most likely to me that the 1st and 3rd Block are the Magnets.

And as you can see in your linked Video, the upper and lower arc are resting on these blocks. So the armature can pass.
This is Mr. Lülings neutralised stage as I conclude.
It feels like I am repeating my self. You can PM me, so we don't litter this thread too much.

It's ok, i seen that marked frame. But don't you see what you call first and third block are but parts of one plate with square hole in the center. But let's say 1st and 3rd block are magnets as you say. Ok, so rotor is attracted to these blocks.

Yea swinging ARC is resting on the "blocks", and how do you u imagine the neutralization here?

[memphiss]

Hi guys, I'm following your reasoning, since I've been studying the Luling engine for some time, I saw that since April you don't write anything anymore, there are no updates, why ...? have you stopped having given up, or have you made progress and keep it to yourself? in any case I am sorry that the tredd has stopped like this ..... I was going to try to make it happen, but without the advice of someone who has tried, I see it hard .... If someone wants to answer me, I'll do it pleasure.