Chas Campbell free power motor

[zero]

Hans,

If you watch the Video,  you can see that the PVC entry Pipes
Are maybe 1.5 ft long, at maybe 30-40 degress slope
downwards.   

This is creating more energy that what you are
calculating for the 2d only drawing..  which is
NOT how Chas's wheel operates.

[Humbugger]

Tinu,
you did not analyze my last picture.
Things change, when you different setups.
I now have always only 1 ball at the right side, not 2.

I will try to calculate it tomorrow with your formulars
and then we will see, where the error is.

Stefan:  Suggestion...use the situation where the diameter of the outer wheel is 3.8673x the inner.  The situation, in any case, where the straight-line distance between ball cup centers is equal to 1 unit.  Then you can figure one ball on the right side 100% of the time over the full 30 degrees..

Hum

[hansvonlieven]

Sorry Stefan, even 29 degrees is not enough, you have still one degree to go where you have 3.6 on one side and zero on the other. THAT is the killer.

Hans von Lieven

[Humbugger]

So you agree Humbugger, that when I can do it with more than 27.7 degrees , that I have overunity
So Chas, go for 29 degrees !

Yes, if he would just put exactly 360/29 (12.41379310...) cups on the wheel, I think it would work.  But only if the cups are those special ones I mentioned previously.  The Panacea brand by Campbell Corp. (only the Rev G or later will work in this application)

I heard they got a big grant and the cups will be ready in a couple of years.

Hum

That is typically,
if you are caught by your own faults, the skeptics can only do
ridicule and never see their own mistakes...

Tell us how you would evenly space a cup every 29 degrees then on a 360 degree circle.  Sometimes pointing out the absurd must be done with absurdity. 

The suggestion that you can arbitrarily decide a random number of degrees to pick for constructing the wheel yet always have evenly spaced cups of an integer quantity is indeed ridiculous.  So I used the tool of ridicule to point it out.  I feel that is fair game in this case.  I am not avoiding any logical argument.  I am returning what is served at me.

Humbugger

[hansvonlieven]

except Hum at 3.8673x the inner you do not have enough torque to lift the other balls

Hans von Lieven