The Master Of Magnetics "Steven Mark"

[bob.rennips]

Hello all,

here the circuit

Otto

Thanks Otto (and sulake for the clean-line version)

I've tried both this circuit and the circuit where the lamp is connected to the minus. In both cases whether the collector is within the coil or not there is no difference.

Can anyone else confirm this, with their setup ?

I assume everyone is aware that a coil has inherent self capacitance so in effect what  you have is an LCR circuit. You would expect an LCR circuit to have a resonant frequency where the voltage is highest.

[Dansway]

@sulake

We are trying to tell/show you that there is something "added" from outside this simple circuit when it runs.
Do the test or not.

~Dan

[bob.rennips]

So it's the same as this in that how it works.
Can you post some pictures of the voltages from your scope?

Please do the test!!!!!

use the correct components arghhh!

Mannix your replies are about as useful as a sponge on the titanic.

We HAVE TRIED the TESTS.
CAN YOU NOT READ.

Further more we have done another test with the COLLECTED NOT being placed WITHIN the coil and get EXACTLY THE SAME VOLTAGES AND RESULTS.

So either we're not using the correct circuit OR your interpretation of your results is hogwash.

To this end we have been trying to pin down exactly what the circuit is to ensure the difference in interpretation is not in this part.

So far we have a circuit with lamp connected to MINUS.
Latest circuit has lamp connected to PLUS.

Secondly, we have asked for other to try THE TEST, but with the collector not within the coil. ANY good experimentor devices further experiements to confirm their interpretation.

I have done this experiement, HAVE YOU ?

[smoky]

Sulake,
People have been at this for some time doing their best within their financial means and abilities to interpret what they find.
Please do not complain or be demanding, just accept what people can do and have done both in testing and contributing.
Best to break out our own test gear and try to replicate and contribute ourselves than try to apply pressure to those like OTTO already doing the hard yards here.

Smoky

[otto]

Hello all,

@Bob

ok, you tried the test. What transistor have you used???

What do you see on your scope??

Please, let us know.

Otto