Testing the TK Tar Baby

[poynt99]

It would be interesting to see the NERD circuit running off 5 or 6 series-connected rechargeable NiCad 9V batteries. 

Would it run indefinitely and/or outlast their rated capacity?

[WilbyInebriated]

You and I both know that the quote is designed to imply that the circuit won't run on a capacitor.  And in English, the symbol " ? " which appears several times in my post, indicates a QUESTION, that is, an interrogative, asking for a clarification of an ambiguity in the original quotation which you are astute enough to point out.

Now, will you deign to apply your wet-noodle skills, such as they are, to the Ainslie claims made in their papers, like the one above, or will you continue to argue about what the meaning of "is" is, like a Bill Clinton clone squirming on the witness stand? No, of course not... you've got better things to do with your time.

How about this: I'll put a battery and a capacitor in black boxes, and run the NERD or Tar Baby or Altoid circuit for a while on each one, and YOU tell me which is the power source, battery or capacitor? When is "immediately" soon enough or long enough ?

you and both know that nowhere in that quote was the word "immediately"...  
so i'll ask again...  even though everyone reading knows you will reply with a logical fallacy again... why are you adding your own arbitrary and whimsical qualifications?

so you applied your wet noodle skills and came up with a good twist of of the truth...imagine that! no, of course not. not until you amend your errors and your whimsical, arbitrary additions... and then there is that mea culpa you owe me...

but you don't have the nerd circuit... so troll, how about you just amend your idiotic lie that the nerds said "immediately".

[TinselKoala]

You are once again the idiot liar, you crap-shooting reprobate with three blond hairs, you. I never said they said "immediately". I was the one who said "immediately" when I pointed out that is what their "explanation" requires. If you examine their "explanation" though, even you will perceive that what is meant by their quotation is that the circuit won't run on capacitors, and the reason is that the oscillations cease. They have also made this claim elsewhere. But you choose to ignore the fact that I have refuted them, yet again, in order to display your fake erudition and your nearsighed attempts at textual deconstruction. That is, for some strange reason, your continuing privilege here, but know this: it just reinforces the opinion that seems to be nearly universally held about you: you are a troll, plain and simple, and you've never been helpful to anyone at all, ever. You probably don't even wash your own socks.
Now I am asking you again: what is the definition of "immediately" in this context? One second? One minute? Five minutes?
Don't bother to answer, I know you are busy trying to fix your bicycle so it doesn't get your pants cuffs dirty while you are on your way to your ambush location.

[anomdeguerre]

You are once again the idiot liar, you crap-shooting reprobate with three blond hairs, you. I never said they said "immediately". I was the one who said "immediately" when I pointed out that is what their "explanation" requires. If you examine their "explanation" though, even you will perceive that what is meant by their quotation is that the circuit won't run on capacitors, and the reason is that the oscillations cease. They have also made this claim elsewhere. But you choose to ignore the fact that I have refuted them, yet again, in order to display your fake erudition and your nearsighed attempts at textual deconstruction. That is, for some strange reason, your continuing privilege here, but know this: it just reinforces the opinion that seems to be nearly universally held about you: you are a troll, plain and simple, and you've never been helpful to anyone at all, ever. You probably don't even wash your own socks.
Now I am asking you again: what is the definition of "immediately" in this context? One second? One minute? Five minutes?
Don't bother to answer, I know you are busy trying to fix your bicycle so it doesn't get your pants cuffs dirty while you are on your way to your ambush location.

The question you are again avoiding was. Why are you adding your own whimsical and arbitrary qualifications?

[TinselKoala]

It would be interesting to see the NERD circuit running off 5 or 6 series-connected rechargeable NiCad 9V batteries. 

Would it run indefinitely and/or outlast their rated capacity?

Yes, it would, but we won't. No it won't, and no it won't.