Ultimate proof of Magnetic Vortex, free book and videos

[picowatt]

TA,

Using various techniques to do so, "something" that follows the domain concept, i.e., magnetically aligned regions, has been imaged within and on the surface of a magnet that at least "looks" like domains as they were originally perceived.  Pre and post magnetization imaging also reveals that these "domains", or "regions" form/align following magnetization.

As for the rest of your response, possibly someone else here that understands what you are saying will be kind enough to explain it further to me so that I too will understand.

PW

[TinselKoala]

 

[picowatt]

TA,

Using various techniques to do so, "something" that follows the domain concept, i.e., magnetically aligned regions, has been imaged within and on the surface of a magnet that at least "looks" like domains as they were originally perceived.  Pre and post magnetization imaging also reveals that these "domains", or "regions" form/align following magnetization.

As for the rest of your response, possibly someone else here that understands your response will be kind enough to explain it further to me so that I too will understand (any takers?).

PW

[TheoriaApophasis]

Pre and post magnetization imaging also reveals that these "domains", or "regions" form/align following magnetization.

YES, Ive seen the same nano-scale images.    Nevertheless, that is still only seeing regions of coherent magnetism, and not that which is producing same which is in fact ITSELF that which was causally aligned and therefore has resultant coherent, or aligned magnetic preponderances.


still a cart before the horse fallacious scenario or CORRECT observations and INCORRECT conclusions.

[picowatt]

YES, Ive seen the same nano-scale images.    Nevertheless, that is still only seeing regions of coherent magnetism, and not that which is producing same which is in fact ITSELF that which was causally aligned and therefore has resultant coherent, or aligned magnetic preponderances.


still a cart before the horse fallacious scenario or CORRECT observations and INCORRECT conclusions.

According to convention, and as surmised long before these imaging capabilities were available, the domains are regions of similar alignment, with "buffering" regions (if you will) of lesser aligned regions in between.  Also according to convention, each domain contains a large number of atomic or molecular structures each having a magnetic moment similarly aligned within a given domain.

When imaging the domains, we see the result of those atomic/molecular alignments reflected as the more macroscopic structures, i.e., domains.

Is this somewhat a question of semantics, that is, do you have a preference for some other word that describes what it is we see and what is referred to as a domain?

PW