Friedrich Luling Magnet Motor

[nix85]

This guy shows how he thinks Luling motor is constructed.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BmGx_XQTOHw

Key point being that magnets are magnetized along the long axis. I believe this way there is less tendency for sticking.

But i am not sure if there are stator magnets as he shows.

Anyway i don't think anyone should build a magnet motor and then fight against lenz.

I see em as toys, a waste of time.

[jimbo]

Thanks for the post but I've never much cared for cad hypotheticals .cads are good for explaining known systems but guessing isn't more than guessing .if he had build a wanky prototype to get the gest of its workings that might work good but just guessing isn't much use .

[nix85]

Welcome. Ofc it's "just" a cad, that is irrelevant, it could as well be a hand sketch.

What matters is the principle. The question if there are stator magnets and are the rotor magnets polarized along the long axis.

Again, low power magnet motor can be built relatively easily, these are toys. Big ones ala Luling would be useful to run a car or a boat but to make a big one one would need to really put himself into it for quite some time and invest money, i know from experience how expensive machining is and how they rarely get things really as you want them, it turns into hell real quick. This is best to play with for someone who has a machine shop and can machine the parts himself. I love the idea, i would do it for fun, but with so many better ways, i see it as waste of time.

Here are few magnet motors. I have no doubt these are real but none of them will give you kilowatts.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VsGhllSgpLU
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Me0s25_Xbnc
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vkcFRLQiVGk
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K73R6dMJRCI
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pYLF9UJDbkU
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PIvZJ9xGutI

[Cadman]

This guy shows how he thinks Luling motor is constructed.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BmGx_XQTOHw

Key point being that magnets are magnetized along the long axis. I believe this way there is less tendency for sticking.

But i am not sure if there are stator magnets as he shows.

Anyway i don't think anyone should build a magnet motor and then fight against lenz.

I see em as toys, a waste of time.

That video has no relation with Lüling's motor, not even close.

It seems clear to me that nobody posting here has made the effort to seriously investigate Semi's efforts. Or some of you have and are just keeping quiet about it.

BTW, the motor in the Lüling video is a crippled, stripped down version that simply demonstrates the principle of how it works.

Cadman

[nix85]

That video has no relation with Lüling's motor, not even close.

It seems clear to me that nobody posting here has made the effort to seriously investigate Semi's efforts. Or some of you have and are just keeping quiet about it.

BTW, the motor in the Lüling video is a crippled, stripped down version that simply demonstrates the principle of how it works.

Cadman

Funny. I'm sure you "know" exactly how it worked and have built a replica at least as powerful as the original, in fact, i'd bet it's already powering your car and your house.