New gravity motor from China

[hartiberlin]

Hi All,
have a look at this machine,
that I just discovered the video on youtube.com:


http://youtube.com/watch?v=gxnHJoyrQpM

What do you think ?
It seems the upfloating weight is trapped inside
the water tube at the  top,
so how can it then be reconnected outside to the
chain to go down ?

[NerzhDishual]

Hi Harti_Berlin

Thanks for the link.
This device sounds very amazing.

Yes, I agree with you, how could the weight be reconnected again to the chain?

Perhaps this apparatus is only a "proof of concept"?

You drop a weight.
It produces some work (overcoming friction losses  and lighting  2 bulbs, while going down).
But it is not the end of the story :you can lift up this weight again.
So you have gained free NRG...

When (if) you find a mean to reconnect this weight to the chain you get some perpetual motion. 

There is some comments in the picture.
Infortunately I c'ant read Chinese. 

Very Best

[FreeEnergy]

perphaps there is actualy 2 weights on the chain, while one weight is halfway falling outside the tube the other weight is inside going up.

[NerzhDishual]

Hi FreeEnergy

I see what you mean.

The simple question could be : is this device demonstrating any "overunity" behavior?

Anyway, IMO,  this machine is very tricky.
The falling weight just fit very well in the "ascending water tube" after diving into the "pool" . Does it not?

Sorry for my English!

Very Best.

[dean_mcgowan]

umm .. so how do you break the vacuum in the tube to get the floaty out without having to genereate a vacuum again (expensive energy wise) .. nope thats why they are stuck there ...