Acoustical feedback energy system

[Willy]

...

[aleks]

Wouldn't want this to forum to fall into the same state of affairs....

Well, you are taking it too hard. First of all, your statement "this does not work" is unsubstantiated - because in the video it does seem to work, at least for some time. You haven't demonstrated an analogous device which you can't make to work. Secondly, I'm trying to rely an idea of "opposition" that IMO permeates ALL "perpetual motion" devices. The reason why opposition may work is that it creates a "clash": while on one hand a piezo-element or voice coil moves under controlled EMF, at the same time it moves in an opposite direction under acoustical pressure, which also creates EMF, but an opposing one. A kind of "stoppage" happens, and on "atomic" level (I'm hypothesizing) such "stoppage" leads to creation of electric potential of yet unknown nature.

[Willy]

Well, you are taking it too hard. First of all, your statement "this does not work" is unsubstantiated - because in the video it does seem to work, at least for some time. You haven't demonstrated an analogous device which you can't make to work. Secondly, I'm trying to rely an idea of "opposition" that IMO permeates ALL "perpetual motion" devices. The reason why opposition may work is that it creates a "clash": while on one hand a piezo-element or voice coil moves under controlled EMF, at the same time it moves in an opposite direction under acoustical pressure, which also creates EMF, but an opposing one. A kind of "stoppage" happens, and on "atomic" level (I'm hypothesizing) such "stoppage" leads to creation of electric potential of yet unknown nature.

IT DOES NOT WORK.

It does not work any more than that monkeys might fly out of my but.

That "it does seem to work " is just a pointless and unintentionally silly statement by you.
Obviously, its SEEMING to work was the whole point as to why someone posted the video on you tube in the first place.

Meanwhile compressed air directed at the magnets causes them to spin and that's all folks.

[aleks]

IT DOES NOT WORK.

Meanwhile compressed air directed at the magnets causes them to spin and that's all folks.

What kind of compressed air makes "Liberty engine 2" spin its motors perpetually? You know, if LE2 works, the posted simple device may work, too. Same principle. Beside that, you obviously missed that the author of the video rotates the device in hands. What compressed air?

Don't turn the talk into talk about impossibility to overcome thermodynamic laws. We are on OU forum after all.

[aleks]

On Nikola Tesla. After studying his published works a bit, I've came to the conclusion he NEVER found a free energy source in OU sense. His major claim is that energy always comes from some "medium" meaning Sun, hydro-energy, or underground heat - these were his "free energy" sources compared to fossil fuels. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Nikola_Tesla_writings


As I've concluded myself, Tesla even did not see his own Tesla Coil fired energy into the depths of the aether. That was the reason Wardenclyffe tower was a flop - it simply wasted energy. Tesla wasn't OU apologist, claims to otherwise are a fantasy. But his electrical engineering works are marvels nevertheless, way ahead of his time.