Chas Campbell free power motor

[esaruoho]

G'day all,

Patrick Kelly from Panacea has just send me the following diagram, which is his take on the Chas Campbell system.



Forwarded without comment at this stage

Hans von Lieven

so.. what was the consensus on this diagram?

[hansvonlieven]

G'day all,

@ Hans
   
   i have never heared Milkovic claim perpetual motion from any of his devices. He claims USABLE energy from the LEVERAGE. i have however seen  MANY OTHER PEOPLE who see his device, claim that it is OU, when it is not.
There is nothing OU about the Milkovic device..

Sorry Smokey, not quite right what you are saying. In 2001 Milcovic published a book called Perpetuum Mobile in which he shows ten such devices, nine of them invented by him and one by someone else. In that book he does claim to have invented perpetual motion with his devices based on secondary oscillations. Unfortunately the book is only available in Serbian.

If you want to order a copy, here is the URL of the order form

http://www.veljkomilkovic.com/KnjigeEng.html#perpetum

Hans von Lieven

[fletcher]

stephan .. I am disappointed you have banned humbugger - every argument requires balance & for the most part he was the voice of reason compared to ash's apparent lack of impartiality, imo.

I remind you that "extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof" - if ash/epi is going to go in to bat so vocally for every FE crusader with a claim then he needs to take note of & incorporate the sceptics concerns about good & reliable/dependable testing technique - otherwise this becomes a farcical game of claim - argument & confusion.

Don't get me wrong - I am just as interested in the next guy here in finding/seeing the real deal - I just don't like being taken on little magical mystery tours every time.

[Unicron]

yes sorry, but what happened to freedom of speech?

[hansvonlieven]

G'day Stefan and all,

I feel I have to jump to the defense of Humbugger here too. We all know that he can be abrasive at times and perhaps he should tone that down a bit. Having said that, I feel that he contributes a lot to the debate, he is evidently a well trained engineer who has a lot of knowledge to share.

It would be a pity to deprive this forum of his expertise for no other reason than his tendency to get into shit fights. Socrates was a very cranky and abrasive fellow too and we all know what happened to him. I would hate to have history repeat itself here.

Hans von Lieven