Young Bangladeshi Scientist's success story Power generation without fuel

[Earl]

Quote from Stefan:

"Only using a transformer, some specialized circuits and devices were used in the generator which cost only a small amount," Kachi said adding that only with the investment of Taka one lakh he can make generator which will be able to generate power upto 10,000 kilowatts.
He expressed his gratefulness to journalist Hasan Nasir who introduced Kachi with Vice President of Chittagong Chamber of Commerce and Industry

I don't trust this story.

All he is asking for is one lakh of Taka. In Indian parlance one lakh is 100.000. {snip}
In my view this story is just like all the others in a similar vein, pure crap.

Hans von Lieven

Hans,
do not interpret what is not there.  Nowhere is the inventor asking for any money.
He never said he was looking for an investment in order to do something or to continue research or do build a production facility, or anything else.

He could just have well said that for an investment of xx you can buy a 10kW Italian snowmobile.

I had the impression that the mentioned sum was a guess-timation of what it would cost to build a 10kW device.  Do not literally interpret the word investment written by a Bangladeshi reporter in a foreign language.  If you read the various stories in this newspaper it is immediately apparent that translations from Bengali to English read sometimes funny.

In Europe, it would cost me more than 1500 USD to buy a mass-produced 10kW fossil-fueled generator made in China by slave labor.  So the quoted price for a 10kW FE machine is nothing to raise any eyebrows or make any conclusions concerning fraudulent claims.

What you should have thought is that there is too little information to make any conclusions whatsoever, so it is not necessary to post any opinion based on no facts.

Until further facts become available, there is no rational reason for anyone to participate in imaginary speculation in this thread.  Save the bandwidth and wait.  Or take a plane to Bangladesh and talk to the Chamber of Commerce and the inventor.  Better to have only 1 page on this thread until further info becomes available, rather than 40 pages of nonsense speculating about this and that.

Earl

[allcanadian]

A better question might be-----
How could one generate usable amounts of energy  --""Only using a transformer, some specialized circuits and devices were used in the generator which cost only a small amount," ?

[hansvonlieven]

Hans,
do not interpret what is not there.  Nowhere is the inventor asking for any money.
He never said he was looking for an investment in order to do something or to continue research or do build a production facility, or anything else.

He could just have well said that for an investment of xx you can buy a 10kW Italian snowmobile.

I had the impression that the mentioned sum was a guess-timation of what it would cost to build a 10kW device.  Do not literally interpret the word investment written by a Bangladeshi reporter in a foreign language.  If you read the various stories in this newspaper it is immediately apparent that translations from Bengali to English read sometimes funny.

In Europe, it would cost me more than 1500 USD to buy a mass-produced 10kW fossil-fueled generator made in China by slave labor.  So the quoted price for a 10kW FE machine is nothing to raise any eyebrows or make any conclusions concerning fraudulent claims.

What you should have thought is that there is too little information to make any conclusions whatsoever, so it is not necessary to post any opinion based on no facts.

Until further facts become available, there is no rational reason for anyone to participate in imaginary speculation in this thread.  Save the bandwidth and wait.  Or take a plane to Bangladesh and talk to the Chamber of Commerce and the inventor.  Better to have only 1 page on this thread until further info becomes available, rather than 40 pages of nonsense speculating about this and that.

Earl

I am not interpreting what is not there. 

This guy is not talking about a 10 KW generator for $1500 he is talking about a 10.000 KW generator for this kind of money.

At this price he would have people rushing him from all over the country. Every little and not so little factory, every workshop would want one. I still don't trust this story. Each electric train could be powered with one of those with power to spare. It is crap.

Hans von Lieven

[Earl]

Hans,

the inventor did not say anything; the reporter scribbled notes and typed from his notes later.  The reporter probably doesn't understand kW from Megawatt.  I don't think it would be any different  for a reporter from France, USA, or AU.

If what a reporter wrote makes no sense whatsoever, but makes perfect sense with 10kW then it is obvious what the inventor meant, but the reporter messed up with one extra letter.

We have trouble descending to the level of comprehension of an average person concerning power levels, but believe me the average person is not capable of recognizing an error of 3 orders of magnitude; whether Watt, kW. or MW:  it is all Greek to them.

Earl

[hartiberlin]

There is a pretty new interview with Mark Goldes on their homepage now:

http://www.magneticpowerinc.com

Surely hopefuly soon their toys will be sold...

Too bad the Bangladesh inventor is not open sourcing it...

All the big companies want only to profit from it and they do is handling this
secretively in the background...

Regards, Stefan,