A machine to convert gravity to mechanical energy # 2

[AB Hammer]

Grayone,
I don’t ignore the answers, the problem is I don’t understand them.

Brian

Most of us who build these devises have thought we had it. And allot of us get the idea in our heads and think this is it. It is harder to admit a mistake, so we tend to try to over complicate what is being said and it comes out in a form of confusion. When we build these devices we see first hand the effects of the whys and why nots, which will allow us to do better designs. Real world experience. The biggest lesson is use the KISS method for every step we take in this game is extra friction.

[brian334]

I will ask the question agian, what phase of my machine won't work?

[mondrasek]

Brian,

The re-designed tank is the one where you are not expanding the entire bottom.  The one from the only example you have shown calculations for here.  The one where you show you can expand only 13.4 square inches.  If you try and draw that tank you will see there is no way to fit those expandable members in both ends as well as your weight inside your 12 x 12 x 12 inch cube and have the 11 inches of stroke for expanding that you used in your calculation.

I have only been showing the flaws in phase one!  Those flaws clearly show that your original tank design would not work at all.  It would never expand as you say it will.

If you are banking on momentum please consider what the terminal velocity in water will be for a 12 x 12 x 12 inch cube that only weighs one pound more than the water it is displacing.  It will drift down ever so slowly due to the drag of the water on all sides.  THAT is an experiment you can try without spending too much time or money!  Don't even worry about getting the dimensions exact.  Take a gallon milk jug, fill it with water and one extra pound of any weight you can find.  Rocks or sand will do fine.  Then drop it in water somewhere.  Tie a string to it so you can see what speed it reaches while falling.  If you can attach a scale to the string and make the string 10 feet long you can see what force you get from the momentum.

M.

[brian334]

M.
My advice is for you to go back to my website http://bsandler.com and re-read the entire post start to finish.
The points you make are addressed at my website.

[AB Hammer]

I will ask the question agian, what phase of my machine won't work?

You will never know until you or someone else builds it.  So why do you keep asking the same question?

The word of man can not bring forth fruit, but the work from his hands.