A machine to convert gravity to mechanical energy # 2

[hansvonlieven]

what do you think makes it lighter? The maximum that it is capable of displacing in addition is 3 lbs, no more. Which still keeps it at the bottom.

Hans von Lieven

[brian334]

Dear Hans,
I don't think you understand the machine.

[hansvonlieven]

No my boy,

You don't understand hydraulics. There is nothing in your machine that an engineer cannot understand. Your underlying physics is wrong. The machine cannot behave like you say in this environment, howevermuch you wish.

This is a clone of a hundred similar designs I have seen, some of them patented, and none of them has ever worked. Do some simple experiments in a fish tank or bathtub and you will see where your errors are.

Hydraulics is a very well understood subject in physics. You really should study it.

Hans von Lieven

[brian334]

Dear Hans,
In detail please explain what phase of my machine won't work?

[AB Hammer]

Greetings Hans

Thanks for stepping in. I don't think brian334  understood my crude blacksmith way of speech, and with your engineering of many years, might get him to understand that he needs to do some test and studies, if he wants to figure this out.

@brian334

Hans is someone who you should never take lightly of what he says.