Quote from: profitis on Today at 02:18:27 AM ---Except that you would be hard- pressed to find flaw with the laws of thermodynamics in order to substantiate this.
--- End quote ---

Quote frm sarkeizen:
'I don't need to.  Bayes rule.  You have to reduce the probability of any hypothesis when it fails to meet the expectation.'

End quote

These two statements are incompatible.you will be required to show how these concentration cells disobey the rules of thermodynamics assymetricly


Quote frm sarkeizen:
'Hence the situation I describe is a correct application of Bayes rule and yours was not. :-)'
End quote

Bullshit.how many people can show that gas concentration cells obey the rules of thermodynamics assymetricly?plenty people man

Quote from: profitis on December 31, 2014, 02:44:40 AM
These two statements are incompatible.you will be required to show how these concentration cells disobey the rules of thermodynamics assymetricly

Nope.  I've already shown that the outcome is not matching the expectation.

Quote
Bullshit.how many people can show that gas concentration cells obey the rules of thermodynamics assymetricly?plenty people man

Either it's easy and obvious or it's not.  If it's not easy and obvious then you've been lying.  If it is, then there is an unmet expectation and we need to devalue a hypothesis.  Let me know which one you decide to go with. :-)

quote frm sarkeizen:'either it's easy and obvious or it's not.  If it's not easy and obvious then you've been lying.  If it is, then there is an unmet expectation and we need to devalue a hypothesis.  Let me know which one you decide to go with. :-)'

End quote

The former.Do you have any nickel sponge lying around @sarkeizen?

Quote from: profitis on December 31, 2014, 12:14:51 PM
The former.

That you've been lying about it being easy and obvious?  Well again, thanks for the Christmas present. :-)

Have you got any nickel sponge lying around @sarkeizen?