quentron.com

[MarkE]

Your supposed to be a scientist @ markeiz.. ugghh mark E.how can you make a daft statement like this: 'somebody is going to have to wait a long time to chek for permanentcy'.how long is a nickel-hydrogen battery supposed to last when short-circuited..2hours, 3? You can short a karpen-style for 6 weeks and ping..springs straight back up to original voltage and power.

LOL:

per·ma·nent
ˈpərmənənt/
adjective
adjective: permanent

    1.
    lasting or intended to last or remain unchanged indefinitely.

An indefinite period is a long, long time.

[sarkeizen]

Yawwwn @sarkeizen.just build the thing and see for yourself.its power density is many many times that of karpens original.

Sorry, compulsive liars on websites are not sufficient reason to build anything.   Only a moron would consider your request a good idea.

I've noticed that you've squirmed away from the idea that you can provide a formal argument...now that you know you can't.  I wonder if this elevates the probability that you either know this kind of thing doesn't work or that you have no such device.  I'll have to think about it.

[profitis]

No only someone who cannot specificly point out the irreversability of hydrogen spillover will build the cell @sarkeizen.you still haven't explained to us how your going to judge an argument formatted your way with little or no knowledge in the field.

[profitis]

Yeah indefinitely means a little bit longer than 2hours @markE.try 60years.

[MarkE]

Yeah indefinitely means a little bit longer than 2hours @markE.try 60years.

60 years is better than 2 years, but hardly qualifies as permanent.  Something that is permanent lasts an indefinite period of time.  Mere mortals are confined to evaluating using finite measures.