Tadahiko Mizuno LENR breakthrough COP of 5 and up to 10 Seeking Replication .

[ChileanOne]

This may seem naïve
is there no way to collect emissions /swabs or what have you, after the hard vacuum is removed and submit for analysis ?

Swabing for gases at so low pressures? I don't think so. This worked for Mizuno at very low pressures. It is one of the very surprizing things in his publication.

[ramset]

 I think you would be surprised at the things some of our members can do inside a vacuum chamber .....
However I'm sure many bright minds have wrestled with a solution.


I must admit I was unaware of that issue of no analysis ...  yes it is very surprising
I will ask a few who might have solutions .


Respect fully
Chet K

[ChileanOne]

I think you would be surprised at the things some of our members can do inside a vacuum chamber .....
However I'm sure many bright minds have wrestled with a solution.


I must admit I was unaware of that issue of no analysis ...  yes it is very surprising
I will ask a few who might have solutions .


Respect fully
Chet K
The point is that Mizuno stated clearly, and Jed Rothwell stressed it very strongly in the weeks since the paper was published, that atempting to replicate without the proper tools was going to be a waste of time. One of the tools specified was a mass spectrometer precisely to verify no outgassing of any kind kept happening, before starting with the experiment.
Deneum claims they did a bake out and the pressure remained steady, but Jed Rotwell insists without gas analysis one is working blind.

[ChileanOne]

You can see the debate is ongoing right at this moment. This screenshot just taken by me.