The Lee-Tseung Lead Out Theory

[spoondini]

Lawrence,
   The scientific explanation has already been presented.  There is no additional kinetic energy to be 'lead out'.  If the pendulum swings for a longer period of time, then it is swinging slower (ie same potential gravitational energy released over longer period of time) or lower.  These toys have existed for hundreds of years, and there is no example of a perpetually swinging magnetic pendulum (at least that I'm aware of).  If additional energy was being created in excess of friction - which should be minimal in a typical pendulum set up - then the pendulum should continuously accelerate until load is attached.

PS - This must be one of the most entertaining posts on the site.  How many of us will sh%t ourselves if the Chinese delegation to the UN starts dropping lead out generators to national leaders from their flying saucers.........

[ltseung888]

Lawrence,
   The scientific explanation has already been presented.  There is no additional kinetic energy to be 'lead out'.  If the pendulum swings for a longer period of time, then it is swinging slower (ie same potential gravitational energy released over longer period of time) or lower.  These toys have existed for hundreds of years, and there is no example of a perpetually swinging magnetic pendulum (at least that I'm aware of).  If additional energy was being created in excess of friction - which should be minimal in a typical pendulum set up - then the pendulum should continuously accelerate until load is attached.

PS - This must be one of the most entertaining posts on the site.  How many of us will sh%t ourselves if the Chinese delegation to the UN starts dropping lead out generators to national leaders from their flying saucers.........

As scientists, we should not just accept one explanation.  The following is another explanation.

When there are no other magnets present and that the magnetic force due to the Earth is small, the magnetic pendulum acts like a non-magnetic pendulum.  When the bob is raised high to one side, the bob will swing with kinetic energy changing into potential energy and vice versa.  There will be loss of energy due to friction, air resistance etc.  The swinging will stop after some time.

When there are other magnets present, additional magnetic forces are at work.  The net force acting on the magnetic bob is no longer purely gravity.  If the net force is different, the work done or energy imparted will be different.  The energy exchange mechanism will be different from the previous case.  There will be horizontal components of the magnetic forces.

Thus it is quite understandable that the swinging time will be different (or much longer) than the previous case.

The additional complication is that the magnetic bob itself will influence the magnetic field from the static magnets.  The resulting picture is much more complex.  More research is needed.

[chrisC]

As scientists, we should not just accept one explanation.  The following is another explanation.
....  More research is needed.

It seems like you really don't understand how scientific research works, no wonder you make a fool of yourself on this forum and others. Scientist 'discover' something new and not taught either by previous experiments and patented technology, they then perform research to back up their new discovery and then, they VERIFY their results in some international accepted publications and so on.

You, unfortunately have no clue and it's not about others 'insulting' you, you just so far off the wall you're not considered a scientist by any recognition of the word. You're just a sad deluded gentleman who continues to deny what you supposedly 'discovered' is gospel! You are what I consider a NUT!

Sorry to be so blunt but you need to know the TRUTH.

Sincerely
chrisC

[markdansie]

@ spoondini & ChrisC
as a kid I loved reading the comic strips for a few laughs. I keep asking myself why I read this thread. I realise that I have a real belly laugh at times, like I did reading the comic strips. I have to take my hat of that there is some entertainment value here.
I am still waiting for quality dillusional people to appear again like Mylow. That was real entertainment and a few people really showed their true colours and got burned(Has anyone contributed to Stirlings pass the hat fund yet? The plan selling business must have dried up)
Kind Regards
Mark

[chrisC]

@ spoondini & ChrisC
as a kid I loved reading the comic strips for a few laughs. I keep asking myself why I read this thread. I realise that I have a real belly laugh at times, like I did reading the comic strips. I have to take my hat of that there is some entertainment value here.
I am still waiting for quality dillusional people to appear again like Mylow. That was real entertainment and a few people really showed their true colours and got burned(Has anyone contributed to Stirlings pass the hat fund yet? The plan selling business must have dried up)
Kind Regards
Mark

@Markdansie

The sad thing is even though many of us find comical value in this thread, Lawrence apparently really think he's found the Holy Grail! So sad, but so true.

cheers
chrisC